While the Government has been quick to question the easing of restrictions in other countries, the Covid-19 stringency index tells another story which may embolden our own approach to elimination
The level of restrictions imposed on the daily lives of New Zealand has always been a delicate piece of public policy requiring a deft touch to sell to the people.
Last March, life in New Zealand changed almost overnight at the announcement of Level 4 restrictions – some of the strictest in the world.
READ MORE:
* MIQueue: What are the alternatives to two weeks in a hotel?
* Covid-19: National and ACT plans to get out of Covid will reveal a divided New Zealand
* Couple stranded in Queensland due to lack of MIQ spots may face $14k pension bill
The upshot has been months without community transmission. New Zealanders were able to pick up business as usual, unless their livelihoods or lives were connected to the border. Safety came at the price of insularity – focusing on the ground beneath our feet rather than tying our fortunes to anything further afield.
Comparing New Zealand’s post-Covid status quo with that of other nations has become a burdensome task – Braeburn apples with blood oranges.
But as vaccination steadily replaces lockdown tactics as the first tool decision-makers reach for in the battle against Covid, New Zealanders could be excused for feeling a little behind other parts of the world.
Perhaps it’s in an attempt to pre-empt these feeling that Prime Minister Jacinda Arden keeps returning to the same well in her messages to the public.
Reminding Kiwis of the restrictions even highly-vaccinated countries are still facing has become a well-worn route for the Prime Minister.
It would certainly comfort New Zealanders to know that despite the lockdown, our cocktail of Covid responses still has one of the best ratios of safety and freedom.
Often this means pointing out that as other countries ‘open up’, they still remain pretty much closed.
But how much of that is factual, and how much of it is just what New Zealanders would like to think?
At a post-cabinet press conference earlier this month, Ardern criticised the assumption that other countries have left restrictions behind.
“Perhaps because we don’t see so much coverage of it any more, and perhaps because it’s been such a long time – it’s easy to assume that other countries don’t have restrictions,” she said. “In fact, most countries have never lost their restrictions. They’ve had them through this entire outbreak.”
In response to allegations in Parliament of a slow vaccine rollout earlier this month, Ardern questioned just how well some countries she said some MPs hold up as “beacons of vaccination” had actually been doing.
“Countries that started their vaccination programmes in earnest in February and even peaked around April or May, in some cases still have restrictions in place,” she said. “They still have gathering limits in place, they still have things that are constraining their everyday lives, and in those places where they don’t have that, they have record hospitalisations.”
However, comparisons show these restrictions generally don’t hold a candle to those used in New Zealand.
The Covid-19 stringency index is a composite measure developed by the University of Oxford which takes into account restrictions such as school closures, workplace closures and travel bans.
By this measure, on Monday, New Zealand – or more accurately Auckland, due to the index’s choice to show the response level of strictest sub-region – has the seventh most stringent approach in the world, behind Uganda, Trinidad and Tobago, Seychelles, Fiji, Venezuela and Sri Lanka.
Meanwhile, Denmark dropped all restrictions earlier this month, despite still reporting hundred of new cases a day.
Although the country has a population close to the size of New Zealand’s, greater healthcare capacity and neighbours right on the doorstep mean it has faced a different pandemic since the beginning.
Nevertheless, as it dropped its last restriction, Ardern cautioned New Zealanders that Denmark wasn’t out of the woods just yet.
“They are continuing of course to keep an eye on what winter means for them and what school children going back into learning environments mean for them,” she said. “The whole world is tentative at the moment.”
‘Tentative’ – it’s an odd word to use to describe Danish authorities as they insist the virus is under control while hundreds of cases pop up a day.
Meanwhile, the United States signalled last week it would soon reopen to fully-vaccinated travellers from 33 countries with high rates of the virus, and Norway followed its southern neighbour in throwing out the Covid rulebook.
For better or worse, much of the world is opening up – but the mood in Wellington at the 1 pm press conference seems to be to minimise this.
Auckland is under much stricter regulation than many other places in the world this week. Any diverting from the sacrifices of social isolation and a city stopped near dead by lockdown by instead examining countries in totally different circumstances can overlook the important context of this.
New Zealand’s response to the Delta outbreak was indeed swift and severe as it gunned for total elimination of the virus.
Researchers looking across a range of countries and their different responses found those that pursued elimination rather than mitigation have not only had fewer deaths, but also better protection from economic fallout and over the span of the pandemic, less impact on the civil liberties of their people.
They found elimination-seeking countries like New Zealand, Australia, Iceland, Japan and South Korea have had around 25 times fewer Covid deaths than other OECD countries that went for ‘living with the virus’.
And across the OECD, economic growth is in the red – bar the five countries that chose elimination, for each of whom GDP growth had returned to pre-pandemic levels in early 2021.
Freedoms were also most severely impacted by countries who chose mitigation, as eschewing swift lockdown measures early on has often mean having tighter and longer lockdowns later on.
But much of the upshot of this strategy presents itself in the long-term, and total elimination wasn’t built in a day.
Ardern tends to downplay the ‘opening up’ of other countries, and in doing so puts out some of the sparks of jealousy that could otherwise grow into flames of disquiet in a country of people still very much secluded from the world.
It also means a focus on the right now which overlooks a comparison with other countries across the entire timespan of the pandemic – from its beginning at the end of 2019, into an indefinite future.
Trying to make comparisons with what life across much of the EU is like this September misses the larger point.
Newsroom
© 2021 Stuff Limited
where to buy cialis without prescription tadalafil liquid
what is tadalafil tadalafil side effects
tadalafil generic where to buy cialis without a prescription
cialis tadalafil https://cialistrxy.com/
tadalafil brands https://nextadalafil.com/
buy cialis pills generic tadalafil from uk
cost tadalafil generic https://cialisicp.com/
tadalafil online with out prescription generic tadalafil from uk
cheap cialis pills for sale tadalafil
prescription tadalafil online cheap generic cialis for sale
tadalafil liquid tadalafil generic
cheap cialis pills for sale cialis without a prescription
tadalafil generic where to buy best price usa tadalafil
tadalafil liquid tadalafil
cialis without a prescription what is tadalafil
cialis cost buy tadalafil
canada generic tadalafil cheap cialis pills for sale
https://extratadalafill.com/ where to order tadalafil tablets
tadalafil side effects best price usa tadalafil
generic cialis online fast shipping tadalafil daily online
https://cialisvet.com/ tadalafil online
cialis tadalafil cialis without prescription
cheapest tadalafil cost cialis without a prescription
generic cialis tadalafil cialis without a prescription
where to buy cialis without prescription tadalafil without a doctor prescription
cialis tadalafil tadalafil online
tadalafil cost in canada cheapest tadalafil cost
buy generic cialis online with mastercard https://cialistrxy.com/
cheap cialis pills for sale buy cialis
https://cialismat.com/ tadalafil drug
buy cialis pills tadalafil generic
https://cialisedot.com/ tadalafil
buy generic cialis online with mastercard tadalafil blood pressure
cialis without prescription cialis cost
where to buy tadalafil on line generic cialis tadalafil
generic cialis tadalafil best price usa tadalafil
generic tadalafil from uk prescription tadalafil online
tadalafil price walmart tadalafil side effects
tadalafil vs sildenafil tadalafil daily dosage
viagra order order viagra
effect of tadalafil on female sanofi tadalafil
c-tadalafil. 40mg yellow/mango tadalafil generico farmacias del ahorro
where to buy generic cialis online safely what is tadalafil
price of stromectol stromectol prices
generic cialis online fast shipping cialis without a prescription
https://extratadalafill.com/ tadalafil daily online
how much does sildenafil cost sildenafil citrate tablets 100mg price
ivermectin 5 ivermectin 0.08
tadalafil 10mg price generic tadalafil india
ivermectin price usa stromectol tablets
ivermectin 5ml ivermectin 9mg
ivermectin lotion for scabies ivermectin pills
stromectol cost buy ivermectin uk
ivermectin 1mg stromectol medicine
ivermectin 24 mg ivermectin 0.1
stromectol price us ivermectin pill cost
ivermectin lotion price ivermectin 3mg price
ivermectin 8000 mcg where can i buy oral ivermectin
ivermectin 2ml purchase stromectol
ivermectin 0.1 ivermectin australia
stromectol 6 mg tablet stromectol 3mg cost
how often can you take cialis cialis mg
cialis going generic coupons for cialis
viagra samples viagra pills
generic viagra sildenafil citrate 50 mg what is sildenafil citrate used for
mildfil tadalafil tablets 5mg how many mg of tadalafil should i take
tadalafil without a prescription texas meds tadalafil
best online pharmacy canada walgreens pharmacy online refill
cialis vs viagra levitra levitra 20 mg price walgreens
online pharmacy fioricet Prograf
prices on cialis cialis effects
canadian xl pharmacy walmart pharmacy refill
Lisinopril canada drugs online
h-e-b pharmacy canadian pharmacy northwest
ivermectin candida ivermectin and coronavirus
ivermectin pill for scabies buy ivermectin cream for humans
cialis 10mg ireland cialis wiki
how do i buy viagra online generic viagra from mexico
online levitra reviews levitra prescription cost
expired cialis cheap cialis by post
what to expect from levitra levitra 100mg pills
generic viagra 150 mg sildenafil without prescription
online canadian pharcharmy wegmans pharmacy
my canadian pharmacy com prescription drugs become illegal when __________.
pharmacy store logo remedy rx pharmacy
canadian pharmacy xanax g and e pharmacy edmonton store hours
saxenda canada pharmacy discount prescription drug
rx choice pharmacy canadianpharmacymeds
canadian drugs northwest pharmacy official canadian pharmacy complaints
provigil 100mg canada order provigil 100mg provigil 100mg brand
order modafinil online cheap provigil us
modafinil cheap cheap provigil 200mg buy provigil sale
modafinil cheap order provigil 100mg generic
prescription drugs definitions stater bros super rx pharmacy
modafinil oral buy modafinil 200mg without prescription brand modafinil 200mg
order provigil 200mg without prescription order modafinil 200mg online cheap
modafinil sale
erythromycin ingredients erythromycin 500mg
modafinil cost provigil 200mg usa
cheap modafinil
erythromycin eye ointment https://erythromycin1m.com/#
how Many Die From Cialis?
online pharmacies in usa
erythromycin eye ointment dosage https://erythromycinn.com/#
order generic provigil 200mg provigil 100mg canada
how Long Till Cialis Starts Working 100%?
erythromycin topical gel low dose erythromycin
when Will Cialis Patent Expire?
erythromycin family buy erythromycin online
erythromycin iv https://erythromycinn.com/#
buy provigil 200mg pills buy provigil
how Much Does Cialis Cost?
uses for erythromycin erythromycin eye ointment dosage
when Will Generic Cialis Be Available Over The Counter?
stromectol generic stromectol 3mg tablets
what is hydroxychloroquine https://hydroxychloroquinex.com/
how to get ivermectin from india where to buy ivermectina 12mg
stromectol online canada http://www.ivermectinusd.com/
plaquenil canada generic plaquenil online hydroxychloroquine tablets buy online
Pingback: 3pigtail
ivermectin 6 mg http://www.ivermectinusd.com/
stromectol price us buy 6mg ivermectin
http://hydroxychloroquinex.com/ buy 200 mg hydroxychloroquine
ivermectin online canada order ivermectin online
https://ivermectinuni.com/ stromectol 3 mg tablets price