Home » General » Environment » Extension of environmental clearance to Tawang hydro projects raises questions
By Nivedita Khandekar
New Delhi, Sep 26 (SocialNews.XYZ) The extension of validity of environmental clearance (EC) given to two hydropower projects in Arunachal Pradesh’s Tawang has been questioned by environmental experts, who claim the authority responsible went beyond its brief.
The Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC) for the River Valley and Hydroelectric projects of the Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change has given extension to two hydropower projects of the NHPC Ltd till June 9, 2024.
Tawang Hydroelectric Project Stage-I of 600 MW as a run of river scheme and the Tawang Hydroelectric Project Stage-II of 800 MW, also as a run of river scheme, were put up before the EAC for extension of validity of environmental clearance during the meeting on September 7.
As per the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification, 2006, the period of validity of the EC is 10 years and extendable for three years in case the project proponent applies within the expiry date of the EC. In this case, the EC was granted on June 10, 2011 to both Tawang I and Tawang II. Both projects could not commence due to non-accord of Forest Clearance by the Ministry.
Earlier, after the NHPC Ltd sought the extension of validity of environmental clearance, one of the observations during the deliberation – as documented in the minutes of the meeting – was: “It appears that the EC originally given in 2011 is for commencement of work and not completion of work. In the past 10 years, work has not commenced due to non-accord of Forest (Stage-I), which is reportedly pending for want of compliance under FRA, 2006 by the government of Arunachal Pradesh. Gram Sabha meetings under FRA 2006, are pending in six out of 13 villages since May 2015, due to local agitation. It may be prudent to firstly modify the condition that the validity is for completion of the project and not for commencement of construction- an approach being adopted in other similar cases.”
The members, on their own, also discussed if the EAC may “also seek inputs from MoP (Ministry of Power) regarding status of the project and their comments on the likelihood of completion of project within the requested time period”.
During the September 7 meeting, one of the members, who is a representative of the Central Electricity Authority (CEA), informed the Committee that implementation of this project “is being actively monitored by the CEA/Ministry of Power with a view to encourage hydro power, particularly in northeast region of the country. CEA/Ministry of Power are of the view that the project may be implemented on priority and NHPC Ltd is also making lot of efforts to execute this project.”
Following which, the minutes of the meeting document reveal, the EAC recommended that, “the Ministry may consider the proposal as recommended for grant of extension in validity of EC dated 10th June, 2011 to Tawang Hydroelectric Project Stage-I of 600 MW”.
But it imposed two additional conditions that the project proponent shall submit Stage-I Forest Clearance for diversion of forest land to non-forestry activity prior of grant of extension in the EC and six-monthly compliance report including status of completion of project shall be submitted to Ministry’s Integrated Regional Office and Ministry of Power.
Similar extension of the EC was sought for Tawang II project, similar discussion ensued, exactly a similar record from previous meeting about how the EAC may seek input from the Ministry of Power was discussed and in similar manner, the member, who is a CEA representative, informed that the “project is being actively monitored by the CEA/ Ministry of Power with a view to encourage hydro power particularly in North-East Region of the Country. CEA/Ministry of Power are in view that the project may be implemented on priority and NHPC Ltd is also making lot of efforts to execute this project.”
And then, similar to Tawang I, the EAC “recommended the proposal for extension in validity of EC” subject to following additional conditions (again similar) that project proponent shall submit Stage-I Forest Clearance for diversion of forest land to non-forestry activity prior of grant of extension in the EC and six-monthly compliance report including status of completion of project shall be submitted to Ministry’s Integrated Regional Office and Ministry of Power.
Opposing the move, Coordinator of the South Asia Network for Dams, River and People (SANDRP), Himanshu Thakkar, said: “The EAC mandate should not be dependent on the developer’s viewpoint. It is none of their concern. EAC’s concern should only be from the environmental compliance issues.”
And it is not just the concern about the mandate, the very composition of the EAC is questionable, experts said.
Legal Initiative for Forest and Environment (LIFE) founder and lawyer Ritwick Dutta has challenged before the Karnataka High Court, the very formation of EAC wherein questions have been raised about Chairman K. Gopakumar’s expertise – “which does not mention a single word about river or environment,” as per Dutta – and also the presence of Balraj Joshi, the former CMD of NHPC Ltd – “which is a direct conflict of interest” for the EAC on River Valley and hydroelectric projects”.
“The HC has, in one of the orders in this ongoing case, already stated that all decisions taken by the ‘EAC on River Valley and Hydroelectric Projects’ are subject to the outcome of this litigation,” Dutta told IANS.
Source: IANS
Gopi Adusumilli is a Programmer. He is the editor of SocialNews.XYZ and President of AGK Fire Inc.
He enjoys designing websites, developing mobile applications and publishing news articles on current events from various authenticated news sources.
When it comes to writing he likes to write about current world politics and Indian Movies. His future plans include developing SocialNews.XYZ into a News website that has no bias or judgment towards any.
He can be reached at gopi@socialnews.xyz
googletag.pubads().definePassback(‘/570043968/socialnews.xyz’, [300, 250]).display();
<!–Copyright 2021 | MH Newsdesk lite by MH Themes–> Copyright 2021 | AGK FIRE INC| Terms of Service / Privacy Policy | Contact Us
https://cialisusdc.com/ tadalafil generic where to buy
tadalafil online with out prescription tadalafil cialis
buy generic cialis online with mastercard https://nextadalafil.com/
generic cialis online fast shipping side effects for tadalafil
https://cialisvet.com/ tadalafil goodrx
tadalafil online with out prescription https://cialisicp.com/
tadalafil best price usa tadalafil
tadalafil without a doctor prescription tadalafil generic
https://cialisedot.com/ cialis without prescription
https://cialisusdc.com/ tadalafil price walmart
tadalafil cialis https://cialismat.com/
where to buy generic cialis online safely buy generic cialis online with mastercard
tadalafil buy generic cialis online with mastercard
cialis tadalafil tadalafil liquid
where to buy cialis without prescription cheap cialis pills for sale
https://cialismat.com/ prescription tadalafil online
tadalafil online https://nextadalafil.com/
tadalafil cost walmart best price usa tadalafil
tadalafil online tadalafil without a doctor prescription
where to get tadalafil https://cialistrxy.com/
side effects for tadalafil tadalafil generic where to buy
tadalafil side effects tadalafil online with out prescription
tadalafil price walmart generic cialis online fast shipping
buying zithromax online
canada generic tadalafil where to buy generic cialis online safely
side effects of tadalafil https://cialistrxy.com/
cialis|buy cialis|generic cialis|cialis pills|buy cialis online|cialis for sale
buy tadalis cialis cost
tadalafil 10 mg cost
buy cialis online canada
where to buy generic cialis online safely tadalafil goodrx
tadalafil cialis cialis cost
tadalafil tablets 10 mg price in india
metformin prices uk
cialis 5mg uk
tadalafil online tadalafil daily online
https://cialisbusd.com/ tadalafil online
order motilium online
cheapest tadalafil cost cheap cialis pills for sale
viagra 100mg buy cheap viagra
tadalafil generic cialis 20 mg tadalafil long term usage
teva sildenafil cost sildenafil spray
https://cialiswbtc.com/ tadalafil without a doctor prescription
ivermectin medicine where to buy ivermectin pills
order tadacip 20 mg
cialis tablets tadalafil generic tadalafil prices
cost of ivermectin lotion oral ivermectin cost
stromectol price usa
is sildenafil generic sildenafil at walmart
ivermectin buy
tadalafil cost daily tadalafil
ivermectin cream 1
cheap viagra overnight viagra soft canada
buy cialis online australia paypal
side effects for tadalafil https://cialisbusd.com/
ivermectin 1 buy ivermectin canada
ivermectin 0.5 ivermectin cream 5%
over the counter sildenafil
ivermectin eye drops order stromectol
tadalafil 5mg tablet online canada
stromectol tab price ivermectin cost in usa
viagra pills online order
stromectol ivermectin tablets ivermectin iv
cytotec pill for sale
buy ivermectin for humans australia ivermectin lotion for lice
ivermectin otc ivermectin 5 mg
stromectol 12mg stromectol australia
ivermectin 10 mg order stromectol online
ivermectin 250ml ivermectin 50mg/ml
ivermectin online ivermectin cost
sildenafil troche viagra
viagra india order viagra online
tadacip vs tadalafil generic tadalafil
cost of sildenafil 20 mg buying sildenafil online
best cheap viagra sildenafil 10 mg daily
north drug store cheap prescription drugs online
online sildenafil canada how to get viagra united states
pharmacy technician salary in canada prescription drugs prices comparison
drugs from canada with prescription canadadrugs pharmacy
medplus pharmacy store locator addiction to prescription drugs
trial pack cialis viagra levitro cialis and adderall
buy cialis ebay find tadalafil tadalafil warnings
buy cheap cialis cialis with dapoxetine for sale
ivermectin for covid treatment ivermectin resistance
sildenafil 100mg purchase viagra without rx
pyrantel vs ivermectin ivermectin for snakes
levitra duration levitra max dosage
cialis no perscription cialis 5mg coupon
where to buy cheap viagra sildenafil 50 mg tablet price in india
cialis in usa buy cialis india
canadian pharmacies compare traveling with prescription drugs
where to buy levitra over the counter levitra orodispersible tablets
compounding pharmacy online cvs pharmacy hours
meds online pregabalin canada pharmacy
Kamagra Polo cialis canada
Seroflo vasco rx specialty pharmacy
pharmacy job canada online pharmacy no presc uk
rx discount pharmacy best online canadian pharmacy 2016
canadadrugsonline reputable canadian online pharmacy
buy modafinil 200mg generic
kamagra oral jelly canadian pharmacy store rating/safety
buy provigil 200mg sale modafinil 200mg brand
buy provigil online purchase modafinil sale
erythromycin lactobionate
provigil cost provigil over the counter provigil online
hcg injections canada pharmacy online pharmacy in india
purchase modafinil pills modafinil for sale online
order modafinil pills buy provigil pill
buy provigil 200mg without prescription buy provigil 200mg online modafinil for sale
order modafinil for sale order provigil without prescription
order modafinil 200mg pill
https://erythromycinn.com/# antibiotic erythromycin
erythromycin oint http://erythromycinn.com/#
provigil 200mg for sale order modafinil 200mg
is erythromycin a penicillin azithromycin and erythromycin
which Is Safer Viagra Or Cialis?
modafinil buy online modafinil cost
how Lo G For Liquid Cialis To Kick In?
erythromycin 250mg tablets erythromycin side effects
how Soon Before Sex Should You Take Cialis?
erythromycin iv erythromycin cost without insurance
order modafinil 200mg pill buy provigil pills modafinil medication
how Long Before Sex Cialis?
erythromycin overdose
which Has Worse Side Effects , Viagra Or Cialis?
when Does Cialis Patent Expire?
hydroxychloroquine where to buy online does hydroxychloroquine require a prescription
http://www.ivermectinusd.com/ ivermectin otc
cheap plaquenil buy 200mg hydroxychloroquine
generic stromectol 6mg
plaquenil otc buy hydroxychloroquine online
ivermectin uk 3mg 6mg 12mg ivermectin from canada
http://www.hydroxychloroquinex.com/ plaquenil where to buy
ivermectin pills stromectol
stromectol how much it cost ivermectin canada
Pingback: 1burlington
https://ivermectinuni.com/ stromectol tablets for sale
order ivermectin online buy generic ivermectin online
pop slots
vegas online slots
free games slots
free video slot machines games
free casino games
quick hit slots on facebook
online dissertation help
dissertation writing support
proposal writing company
best usa casinos
online casino us
real casino games
online casino us
online casino usa
usa online casino
online real money casino
mobile casino online
online casino play for real money
sign up casino bonus
casino no deposit sign up bonus
free sign up bonus no deposit casino
blackjack payout
online casino no deposit bonus
free casino bonus
casino games that pay real money
online casino review
online real money casino
online casinos usa
online casino bonus no deposit
online american casinos
casino online usa
best online casinos for usa players
free casino bonus