Jump to navigation
Philanthropy is sometimes described as a ‘privilege’ of the wealthiest. But, as Michelle Wright argues, research suggests that giving circles can provide a meaningful and empowering experience at all levels.
Many of our audience strategies in the arts are focussed on current populations. Yet we only need to look ahead 10 years to 2031 to see the pace of demographic change. For example, life expectancy will continue to increase, 11.3 million people will live on their own and ethnic populations will make up 15% of the population in England and 37% of the population in London.
These projections have urgent implications. For those arts organisations with well thought through education programmes, we can hope to see changes in audience profile in the coming years. However, for fundraisers, it can be difficult to know how to grow giving without expending vast resources to engage with particular communities that may have previously been excluded from the arts.
One way into giving from non-traditional arts-based communities is via giving circles. A giving circle is a form of network philanthropy where groups of individuals donate their money and time to establish and run a funding ‘pool’ and then as a group decide where to give funds away.
This type of philanthropic support is flat in structure and democratic. Groups of people come together to fund something that is important to them, which in turn strengthens their commitment, having a self-reinforcing effect. A great example is the Philadelphia Black Giving Circle, which aims to cultivate charitable giving amongst the black community.
In fact, variations of this type of community support have been around for many years such as Ayuuto, a savings model found in the Somali community. Between 10-15 Somali women will pool a significant amount of money, around $1,000/month for about a year. Each month, one woman from the group receives the entire amount in that pool to apply towards the purchase of a car or start a new business.
Traditionally in the arts, we have institutional giving circles, such as the Chairman or Artistic Director Circles, which we see at organisations like English National Opera and the V&A. The annual membership is around £10,000 and provides benefits such as priority booking and special previews. For the most part, these circles are like any other membership scheme, offering set benefits in return for a fee.
Another model is the facilitated giving circle such as those developed by organisations like BeyondMe or the Suffolk Community Foundation. These help people to establish a circle, set goals and connect them to causes.
But the main interest at Arts Fundraising & Philanthropy, is the self-initiated giving circle. These are (usually) small groups of friends (or other closely connected social networks), who may meet in living rooms or pubs – such as Kew Group in South London (where members give c.£50-100 per month) or Give Inc in Ireland (where members give £1 a day) – to discuss which causes they want to support.
These self-initiated giving circles have a variety of dimensions – offering their members enjoyable social interactions, intellectual stimulation and satisfaction, as well as the opportunity to learn and deepen understanding of community issues. The groups set their own rules and decide what is important, free from the direction of an institution.
Giving circles can range in size from a handful of members to several hundred. Funding is usually given to multiple organisations and projects, although some support one particular cause or charity.
The structure can be informal or formal. On the informal side, circles may vote and choose an organisation to support and each member contributes. Formal circles may have their money housed at a local community foundation, the Charities Aid Foundation (CAF), or set up a bank account.
Despite being spontaneous and informal, independent giving circles develop their own system of self-imposed rules, such as having an all-female membership, agreeing a set amount that each will give, how often the group will meet and determining which causes the group will and won’t support.
Collective giving or network philanthropy is relatively unchartered in the UK, with most charities focussing on individual relationships (e.g. between a philanthropist and the charity). However, we have seen the rise of great examples of community action and giving, such as FoodBanks, with 2,000 local branches nationwide, run by volunteers predominantly through Christian churches, but supported by other faiths, such as Muslim and Sikh, or those with no faith allegiance.
A 2007 survey of 160 giving circles in the US, More Giving Together found they had leveraged nearly $100 million. Nearly 12,000 people took part in the 160 giving circles surveyed. This suggests that an average annual amount given could be around $1,000. The research said, “popularity of giving circles is also growing among racial, ethnic and tribal communities as well as in the gay and lesbian community”.
In the UK, data are lacking, but looking at those participating in giving circles led by BeyondMe, the average giving amongst this group was £1,000, representing at most 2% of post-tax income for these mostly young, wealthy, city professionals.
Giving circles offer optimism to charities and the arts sector in their broad potential to increase individual giving and to attract new, younger, and more diverse people to philanthropy. Their success depends on volunteer leadership. Felicia Herman, Executive Director, The Natan Fund (A Jewish giving circle) says: “Giving circles successfully engage new people in a thoughtful, strategic and social experience of philanthropy: first generation wealth holders, young people, women, people without significant wealth who nevertheless want a thoughtful and strategic experience of giving”.
Eikenberry’s 2009 report addresses charities’ fears that giving circles may divert funds away from them and towards other causes. She says “research shows that giving circle members tend to give more and give more broadly as a result of participation, rather than shift their giving”.
The institutional loss of ‘control’ over giving programmes is only a perceived threat because organisations don’t have much control over giving choices to start with. In fact, grassroots philanthropy could be an incredible way to build better philanthropy cultures across diverse communities across the UK.
In November 2019, Arts Fundraising & Philanthropy hosted an event on the value of networks, which supported Akulah Agbami, Director of to deliver three days of fundraising training across the Black* Artists on the Move network. Akulah said that in addition to supporting the development of professional fundraising skills, they wanted to emphasise network philanthropy: “We encouraged artists in different geographical areas to develop ‘funding circles’: whether they be monthly get-togethers in local libraries, online check ins, or peer-to-peer application critique groups. It is these networks that make us more resilient, foster new ideas and innovation in fundraising, and that ultimately will allow us to make more art”.
The impact of giving circles in diverse communities is significant – it is a grassroots movement towards communities identifying and solving needs and problems in their own communities
At Arts Fundraising & Philanthropy via our networks funding we are about to invest in a range of self-initiated giving circles in the area of the arts. If you are interested to apply for support to seed fund a giving circle, you can do so here.
Michelle Wright is CEO of Cause4 and Programme Director of the Arts Fundraising & Philanthropy Programme. (With thanks to Anna Pharoah for support with research.)
This article is part of a series on the theme Fundraising for the Future, contributed by Arts Fundraising & Philanthropy.
The UK City of Culture is a DCMS success story by any standards. But, as Andrew Dixon explains, serious flaws in this year’s bidding process have been likened to “sitting an exam before you’ve read the syllabus”.
The shift to digital has been beneficial to many, but Ash Mann is particularly interested in what it could mean for D/deaf, disabled and neurodivergent people.
As arts organisations struggle to fill critical roles, Amanda Parker shares must-dos – and must don’ts – for those hoping to recruit a talented, experienced and inclusive workforce.
Do you have something to share with the rest of the arts sector? Find out more about writing for ArtsProfessional here.
More jobs
buy cialis pills cialis cost
https://cialisvet.com/
where to buy cialis without prescription tadalafil goodrx
https://cialismat.com/ buy tadalafil
generic tadalafil from uk best price usa tadalafil
where to get tadalafil cost tadalafil generic
best price usa tadalafil tadalafil cost in canada
cheapest tadalafil cost side effects of tadalafil
tadalafil generic tadalafil online with out prescription
tadalafil online generic cialis online fast shipping
tadalafil price walmart best price usa tadalafil
tadalafil side effects tadalafil without a doctor prescription
tadalafil cialis cialis without a prescription
cheapest tadalafil cost tadalafil liquid
generic cialis tadalafil https://cialismat.com/
side effects of tadalafil cost tadalafil generic
buy generic cialis online with mastercard https://cialisusdc.com/
where to order tadalafil tablets best price usa tadalafil
https://cialisicp.com/ what is tadalafil
https://cialisbusd.com/ what is tadalafil
tadalafil cost in canada https://cialistrxy.com/
cialis without a prescription what is tadalafil
cialis cost tadalafil daily online
tadalafil liquid tadalafil side effects
https://cialisbusd.com/ tadalafil goodrx
cost cyclobenzaprine 15mg
best price usa tadalafil tadalafil
cyclobenzaprine 15mg uk
where to get tadalafil generic cialis online fast shipping
order cyclobenzaprine pill
https://cialisicp.com/ generic cialis online fast shipping
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg online
flexeril over the counter
online pharmacy viagra no prescription
buy flexeril 15mg sale
can i buy cialis in canada
buy cyclobenzaprine sale
viagra coupon canada
order flexeril 15mg online cheap
where to buy cialis without prescription buy cialis
buy cyclobenzaprine online cheap
buy flexeril online
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg sale
rx azithromycin
order flexeril 15mg without prescription
canada generic tadalafil buy cialis pills
order cyclobenzaprine online cheap
cialis|buy cialis|generic cialis|cialis pills|buy cialis online|cialis for sale
cheap cyclobenzaprine 15mg
buy viagra cialis
cheap generic viagra
flexeril 15mg canada
tadalafil canada 20mg
buy cyclobenzaprine online cheap
order flexeril 15mg without prescription
canada generic tadalafil side effects for tadalafil
purchase cyclobenzaprine generic
flexeril 15mg generic
cost of cialis tadalafil online with out prescription
flexeril pill
generic viagra 25mg
cyclobenzaprine over the counter
buy cialis canada paypal
order flexeril pill
order flexeril 15mg pills
viagra online canadian pharmacy
flexeril 15mg over the counter
buy flexeril 15mg generic
erectafil 20 online
cyclobenzaprine cheap
flexeril 15mg brand
synthroid online paypal
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg sale
https://cialistrxy.com/ tadalafil goodrx
order flexeril
cyclobenzaprine 15mg generic
https://flexeril.store/
hydroxychloroquine prices
tadalafil online with out prescription https://nextadalafil.com/
purchase flexeril without prescription
tadalafil cost walmart where to buy generic cialis online safely
purchase cyclobenzaprine sale
where can you get erythromycin
cheap generic cialis for sale generic cialis tadalafil
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg pills
flexeril 15mg generic
purchase generic cialis online
buy cyclobenzaprine pills
viagra 200mg price in india
buy flexeril online cheap
ivermectin generic
cyclobenzaprine online buy
generic flexeril
cyclobenzaprine 15mg price
buy erectafil
flexeril 15mg canada
cheap cialis prices
buy flexeril pill
best price usa tadalafil where to buy cialis without prescription
flexeril us
where to get tadalafil tadalafil generic
buy cyclobenzaprine online
motilium generic brand
cipla tadalafil 20 mg review liquid tadalafil 30mg spray
purchase cyclobenzaprine online cheap
purchase cyclobenzaprine pill
lowest price cialis tadalafil side effects
cost cyclobenzaprine 15mg
buy flexeril sale
best price usa tadalafil https://cialismat.com/
cyclobenzaprine for sale
order flexeril sale
where to buy tadalafil in singapore tadalafil half life
flexeril price
sildenafil 100mg dosage canandaigua pharmacy sildenafil
flexeril 15mg usa
purchase flexeril online
buy daily cialis
cyclobenzaprine oral
flexeril online
how much is ivermectin ivermectin brand
tadalafil 30mg per ml x 30 ml tadalafil 20mg price
cyclobenzaprine 15mg cost
buy cyclobenzaprine online cheap
order flexeril sale
stromectol 12mg
where to buy cialis without prescription tadalafil drug
cyclobenzaprine without prescription
stromectol tablets ivermectin rx
cost cyclobenzaprine 15mg
flexeril online
cheapest tadalafil cost buy cialis pills
cyclobenzaprine order online
ivermectin ivermectin 1 cream
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg without prescription
ivermectin 2 stromectol price in india
flexeril for sale
order generic flexeril 15mg
prednisone pak
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg sale
buy generic cyclobenzaprine 15mg
cephalexin 500mg buy
purchase flexeril online cheap
buy ivermectin for humans uk buy stromectol canada
order generic flexeril
buy cyclobenzaprine sale
tadalafil prices 5mg
oral flexeril 15mg
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg pills
flexeril 15mg for sale
cialis 40mg generic
how much does ivermectin cost stromectol
generic cyclobenzaprine
stromectol order online
order flexeril without prescription
1 viagra pill
cyclobenzaprine ca
cyclobenzaprine online order
flexeril online
otc generic cialis
brand flexeril 15mg
order cyclobenzaprine for sale
flexeril 15mg uk
ivermectin 3mg
order generic cyclobenzaprine 15mg
buy cyclobenzaprine online
buy flexeril pill
[url=http://cialisztabs.shop/]cialis 40 mg generic[/url]
cyclobenzaprine for sale
order cyclobenzaprine sale
viagra tablet canada
buy flexeril 15mg without prescription
cialis buy online usa
flexeril 15mg sale
ivermectin drug ivermectin buy uk
ivermectin 2
cyclobenzaprine order online
purchase cyclobenzaprine pill
cyclobenzaprine us
lyrica 150
cyclobenzaprine tablet
cyclobenzaprine for sale online
indocin medicine
flexeril order
buy ivermectin stromectol
cyclobenzaprine 15mg pills
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg pill
cialis 5mg uk
flexeril 15mg generic
purchase cyclobenzaprine online cheap
best price for sildenafil 100 mg
celebrex pfizer
buy flexeril 15mg without prescription
flexeril cheap
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg online
ivermectin 8000 mcg purchase oral ivermectin
flexeril 15mg drug
combivent hfa
flexeril ca
ivermectin generic name ivermectin pill cost
cyclobenzaprine usa
online lexapro
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg sale
oral cyclobenzaprine 15mg
order flexeril without prescription
buy vermox online
cost cyclobenzaprine
buy cheap amoxicillin
30mg amitriptyline
buy cyclobenzaprine online
viagra cost australia
cyclobenzaprine drug
buy flexeril pill
stromectol pill
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg generic
topical ivermectin cost stromectol tablet 3 mg
buy flexeril for sale
buy flexeril 15mg without prescription
cheap viagra uk sildenafil 100 mg
flexeril 15mg us
buy keflex online australia
order flexeril 15mg online
flexeril us
cafergot tablets price
flexeril 15mg canada
buy cyclobenzaprine for sale
ivermectin otc stromectol lotion
brand cyclobenzaprine
order cyclobenzaprine online
cialis meme canadian online pharmacy cialis
buy cyclobenzaprine
triamterene/hctz 37.5
flexeril medication
flexeril pills
ivermectin coronavirus ivermectin tablets order
augmentin 875 mg buy
buy generic cyclobenzaprine 15mg
keflex 750 mg price
generic flexeril
generic viagra online pharmacy
cyclobenzaprine 15mg us
buy generic flexeril
order flexeril for sale
viagra online from mexico
order cyclobenzaprine online cheap
buy flexeril sale
sildenafil gel india
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg for sale
flexeril 15mg canada
cialis uk 20mg
order flexeril online
purchase flexeril online cheap
viagra cream
buy flexeril 15mg online cheap
tretinoin 1 gel coupon
buy cyclobenzaprine without prescription
flexeril 15mg canada
celebrex gel
order cyclobenzaprine pills
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg without prescription
sildenafil 50 mg online buy sildenafil us
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg online cheap
order flexeril generic
tadalafil natural tadalafil professional 20 mg
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg pills
flexeril pills
amoxicillin 500 mg order online
order flexeril 15mg generic
oral flexeril 15mg
cyclobenzaprine 15mg uk
stromectol tablets uk
flexeril online
cyclobenzaprine sale
pharmacy prices for amoxicillin
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg pills
flexeril uk
oral cyclobenzaprine
female viagra capsules in india
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg sale
sildenafil citrate over the counter viagra pill price in mexico
flexeril 15mg uk
can you buy doxycycline over the counter australia
cyclobenzaprine uk
propecia online singapore
cyclobenzaprine pill
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg generic
best propecia brand
viagra 250 mg
generic flexeril
cyclobenzaprine online order
cvs pharmacy refill online canada ed drugs
buy flexeril for sale
flexeril 15mg generic
purchase zithromax
purchase cyclobenzaprine for sale
can i buy cialis in canada over the counter
cyclobenzaprine medication
brand cyclobenzaprine
5 mg cialis cialis daily side effects
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg sale
cyclobenzaprine 15mg generic
viagra pills price in south africa
cyclobenzaprine for sale online
cyclobenzaprine pills
generic for propecia
flexeril online
ivermectin iv
brand cyclobenzaprine
buy flexeril 15mg online cheap
buy flexeril sale
cialis purchase online uk
flexeril 15mg generic
order flexeril 15mg online cheap
oral cyclobenzaprine 15mg
clomid over the counter uk
flexeril 15mg uk
flexeril buy online
best price tadalafil 10mg
order generic cyclobenzaprine 15mg
prednisone 50 mg tablet
flexeril 15mg cost
flexeril for sale online
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg pills
generic ivermectin cream
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg online
order flexeril without prescription
is it illegal to carry prescription drugs without the bottle family pharmacy
order flexeril 15mg
purchase cyclobenzaprine for sale
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg without prescription
diflucan for sale online
purchase cyclobenzaprine online cheap
pharmacy tech salary pharmacy discount card
flexeril drug
order stromectol online
flexeril buy online
levitra drugstore levitra clinical data
buy cyclobenzaprine pills
[url=https://flexeril.store/]buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg pill[/url]
can you buy sildenafil online
buy cyclobenzaprine for sale
purchase cyclobenzaprine online cheap
order cyclobenzaprine pill
purchase clomid australia
order cyclobenzaprine without prescription
cyclobenzaprine brand
stromectol sales
order flexeril 15mg online cheap
tadalafil back pain what is tadalafil tablet
cyclobenzaprine 15mg oral
cyclobenzaprine sale
viagra pro
buy flexeril 15mg online
sildenafil online without prescription
prednisone 10mg for sale
oral flexeril 15mg
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg pills
ivermectin 8000 mcg
purchase flexeril pill
order flexeril 15mg pills
modafinil how to get
cyclobenzaprine for sale online
order zovirax pills
cyclobenzaprine 15mg tablet
vardenafil 40 mg online
cyclobenzaprine 15mg drug
buying lisinopril in mexico
buy flexeril 15mg for sale
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg for sale
cheap cialis online generic viagra cialis trail pack
generic flexeril
cyclobenzaprine without prescription
ivermectin cream side effects ivermectin covid uptodate
diflucan over the counter south africa
viagra online india
propecia price comparison
purchase cyclobenzaprine
stromectol ivermectin 3 mg
where can i buy baclofen
buy flexeril sale
brand cyclobenzaprine 15mg
erythromycin estolate
flexeril 15mg over the counter
flexeril cost
order flexeril 15mg pill
cheapest soft viagra soft on line viagra online prescription uk
flexeril pills
order flexeril for sale
can you use ivermectin on cats buy stromectol online no prescription
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg online
buy doxycycline us
cost flexeril
cyclobenzaprine drug
advanced rx compounding pharmacy cost of prescription drugs
buy flexeril generic
cyclobenzaprine tablet
how to get viagra online
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg for sale
buy genuine viagra online uk
buy flexeril 15mg pills
cyclobenzaprine 15mg us
cyclobenzaprine pill
metformin 5000 mg
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg sale
buy amoxicillin 875 mg online
flexeril 15mg price
trazodone tablets
order flexeril pill
buy cyclobenzaprine online
price of trazodone
cheap cialis generic 10mg cialis
1500 mg amoxicillin
cyclobenzaprine canada
order flexeril for sale
cost of prednisolone uk
order flexeril pills
doxycycline cheap canada
flexeril 15mg cheap
price of amoxicillin 875 mg
order generic cyclobenzaprine 15mg
where to buy vermox
buy viagra toronto purchase sildenafil pills
paroxetine generic india
cyclobenzaprine pills
cyclobenzaprine over the counter
buy retin a in mexico
levitra 100mg guaranteed lowest price levitra efectos secundarios
order cyclobenzaprine online
buy cyclobenzaprine pill
stromectol price uk
cyclobenzaprine ca
cyclobenzaprine 15mg pills
amitriptyline buy
cyclobenzaprine 15mg for sale
buy lasix uk
order flexeril 15mg pill
viagra online buy usa
order flexeril pill
cost cyclobenzaprine
buy female viagra australia
flexeril sale
buy generic cyclobenzaprine
lasix 40mg to buy
flexeril 15mg generic
flexeril over the counter
lyrica price in mexico
cyclobenzaprine without prescription
cyclobenzaprine order
flexeril 15mg sale
prednisolone cream uk
flexeril order
cyclobenzaprine 15mg over the counter
planet drugs direct canada canadapharmacy24h
generic flexeril
cialis covered by insurance buy original cialis online
cyclobenzaprine without prescription
oral cyclobenzaprine
order cyclobenzaprine online cheap
dose levitra best time to take levitra