Become a supporter
via PressPatron
Between 2012 and 2018, NZ lost the equivalent of more than 12,000 rugby pitches of Indigenous habitat to agriculture and urban development. Photo: Lynn Grieveson
Professor Catherine Iorns is in the Faculty of Law at Te Herenga Waka—Victoria University of Wellington and an adviser to the Environmental Law Initiative.
Dr Matthew Hall is a senior environmental researcher at the Environmental Law Initiative Trust.
Ideasroom
If we are serious about “environmental limits” then they need to be limiting. Dr Catherine Iorns and Dr Matthew Hall make a case for why the Natural and Built Environments Bill must be re-drafted to ensure a pivotal role for independent science.
The Environment Select Committee analysing submissions on the exposure draft of the Natural and Built Environments Bill may have been surprised by the spectrum of support for biophysical limits for the environment. But when Auckland Council, Beca, EDS, Fonterra, Forest & Bird, the Freshwater Iwi Leaders Group, Ngāi Tahu and the NZ Construction Industry all agree on an environmental proposal, it’s clear something might be up.
At the heart of the bill is a key proposal: the concept of environmental limits. Gaining global recognition as a key framework for ecological wellbeing, limits serve as biophysical “bottom lines” for what are considered acceptable levels of interference with the natural world.
The Government’s own statistics make our environmental predicament crystal clear: on most major environmental indicators, Aotearoa is in a precipitous decline.
Between 2012 and 2018, we lost the equivalent of more than 12,000 rugby pitches of Indigenous habitat (12,869ha) to agriculture and urban development. This rampant and ongoing conversion of New Zealand’s environment to human ends is putting untold pressures on our plant and animal life, with huge swathes of Indigenous species now at risk of extinction.
It is also having well-documented effects on the water quality of our rivers and lakes. Based on the latest statistics, more than half of our lakes are regarded as having “poor” or “very poor” water quality, and 68 percent of monitored groundwater sites do not meet E.coli drinking water standards.
Even to those who profit handsomely from extractive industries, it is clear something has to change. And yet, the savvy resource management operators in New Zealand know that the devil is in the details. Resembling something of an all-you-can-eat buffet, the current draft bill uses limits in such a way that everyone can see something they like.
In the exposure draft, compliance with limits is required to achieve the purpose of the Bill, but at the same time the draft retains the option of mitigating environmental damage. The implication here is that limits are not actually biophysical boundaries but rather “soft” limits that can be adjusted according to the circumstances. Submitters such as the NZ Property Council and Straterra would like limits that are “flexible” and “agile” rather than limits that are hard and fast. But the very idea of “flexible limits” is a paradox: limits that can be bent are not limits at all, they’re merely guidelines.
Another area of ambiguity is what environmental limits may actually cover. Going against the recommendations of the Government’s own report, the bill currently only lists general subject areas for which limits must be set (e.g. freshwater quality), without any precise details about what exactly limits will be set for (e.g. dissolved inorganic nitrogen).
Then there is confusion about where the level of limits should be set, as the exposure draft is silent on this point. The current drafting suggests that limits may be formulated as the “minimum biophysical state” or the “maximum amount of harm” to the environment. This potentially renders our most stable ecosystems vulnerable, by allowing further degradation to the point at which the ecosystem can take no further harm. Worse, for ecosystems that have already been pushed way beyond their limit, there’s nothing here that will drive the improvement required to get them even to the biophysical minimum.
Additionally, the exposure draft proposes that environmental limits will be set by the Minister for the Environment, but the role of independent science (including mātauranga Māori) in limit-setting is unclear. What is clear is that many submitters are skeptical of political interference in setting environmental limits. The NZ Māori Council hit the nail on the head by pointing out that having ministers set limits “will politicise this process and ultimately undermine one of the main purposes of the act”.
Clearly there’s a lot more work to be done to get this fundamental pillar of the draft bill fit-for-purpose.
If we are serious about “environmental limits” then they need to be limiting. The ordinary application of the word “limit” implies a point beyond which something may not extend, and a restriction on the size or amount of actions permissible or possible.
Environmental limits therefore need to actually restrain activities, such as conversion of Indigenous habitats, which continue to drive environmental degradation. They need to restrain detrimental activity even if it’s inconvenient for vested interests. They need to be hard limits, beyond which it is not legally possible to extend; they can’t be flexible limits ignored for the right development. If limits are not achievable or practical under current circumstances, that is good, because that is the point. But instead of then bending those limits for “business as usual”, we must be brave enough to use them as tools for fundamentally rethinking the way we do things.
It’s not always easy to pinpoint the maximum amount of harm an ecosystem can take. Ecosystems don’t respond to pressure in a linear fashion. Feedback loops and tipping points make limits hard to determine. Often, we only know once they’ve been passed. To avoid past mistakes, scientific experts must have a strong role in limit-setting and achieving what leading scientists have called a “safe operating space” for human society.
We’ve outlined a couple of options in our submission on the bill, including setting up an independent expert body similar to the Climate Commission that determines what relevant science requires. The Government’s own report on environmental limits recommended the same.
We couldn’t put it better than Federated Farmers, which argues forcefully that “environmental limits cannot be simply left to executive decision-making and political whims”.
For limits to work, the bill must be re-drafted to ensure a pivotal role for independent science. The stakes will simply not allow for anything else.
Additional authors:
Allan Brent is a senior adviser and conservation law researcher at the Environmental Law Initiative.
Molly Robson is a communications adviser at the Environmental Law Initiative Trust.
Help us create a sustainable future for independent local journalism
As New Zealand moves from crisis to recovery mode the need to support local industry has been brought into sharp relief.
As our journalists work to ask the hard questions about our recovery, we also look to you, our readers for support. Reader donations are critical to what we do. If you can help us, please click the button to ensure we can continue to provide quality independent journalism you can trust.
Read and post comments with a
Newsroom Pro subscription.
Subscribe now to start a free
28-day trial.
How many people have been vaccinated in NZ? Newsroom presents a weekly dashboard of everything you need to know about our vaccine rollout.
Marc Daalder
PM and Dr Bloomfield can’t rule out pre-flight testing exemption lead to outbreak.
Jo Moir
Pāmu wants to establish 10,000 hectares of new plantation forest by 2030. David Williams reports
David Williams
Start your day with a curation
of our top stories in your inbox
With thanks to our partners
Start your day with a curation of
our top stories in your inbox
Dummy text
tadalafil dosage https://cialisicp.com/
tadalafil goodrx generic cialis tadalafil
tadalafil cialis tadalafil cost walmart
https://cialisbusd.com/ generic tadalafil from uk
best price usa tadalafil https://cialistrxy.com/
cialis cost buy tadalis
tadalafil price walmart https://cialisedot.com/
buy cialis https://cialismat.com/
tadalafil goodrx tadalafil online
buy tadalis cialis without a prescription
what is tadalafil https://cialisedot.com/
buy tadalis where to buy cialis without prescription
tadalafil cost walmart https://nextadalafil.com/
tadalafil drug tadalafil cost walmart
buy cialis pills tadalafil cost in canada
where to buy tadalafil on line cheap generic cialis for sale
buy tadalafil cheap generic cialis for sale
buy cialis where to buy tadalafil on line
where to order tadalafil tablets buy cialis
where to buy generic cialis online safely tadalafil liquid
tadalafil liquid tadalafil drug
best price usa tadalafil https://cialisedot.com/
lowest price cialis lowest price cialis
cost tadalafil generic side effects of tadalafil
cheap cialis pills for sale tadalafil price walmart
tadalafil where to buy cialis without prescription
tadalafil generic where to buy cialis tadalafil
buy tadalafil tadalafil generic where to buy
tadalafil drug tadalafil without a doctor prescription
cost tadalafil generic tadalafil blood pressure
tadalafil online with out prescription where to buy generic cialis online safely
https://cialisbusd.com/ cialis without prescription
buy cialis pills cheap generic cialis for sale
tadalafil liquid generic cialis online fast shipping
cialis cost tadalafil cost walmart
tadalafil generic where to buy where to buy cialis without prescription
tadalafil price walmart canada generic tadalafil
how to make sildenafil citrate sildenafil viagra
ivermectin goodrx ivermectin 3 mg tablet dosage
ivermectin price usa ivermectin generic
generic sildenafil coupon viagra soft gel
side effects for tadalafil cheap cialis pills for sale
generic cialis online fast shipping tadalafil brands
generic cialis tadalafil tadalafil cost walmart
stromectol drug ivermectin 1%cream
ivermectin price usa ivermectin 3mg for lice
purchase ivermectin stromectol lotion
how much is ivermectin ivermectin 1 cream 45gm
ivermectin 0.5 stromectol south africa
ivermectin 3mg ivermectin 3mg for lice
ivermectin 4 tablets price ivermectin 50mg/ml
purchase stromectol ivermectin lotion for scabies
ivermectin 0.5 lotion india ivermectin 0.5
stromectol generic name generic ivermectin cream
viagra cialis or levitra cialis 60 mg
200 mg sildenafil citrate sildenafil in dogs
cheap cialis buy tadalafil
farmacia genericos comprar cialis generico online tadalafil precio goodrx tadalafil
cheap viagra uk viagra cheap
cvs pharmacy update insurance online canadian pharmacy viagra generic
viagra for women discount viagra
quality rx pharmacy generic viagra online pharmacy
maximum dose of cialis in 24 hours how much is cialis in canada
va pharmacy rules for taking prescription drugs on airplane
levitra reviews by women best place to buy levitra online
best price for sildenafil cheap viagra with prescription
cialis payment with paypal cialis 25mg canada
ivermectin for scabies dosing eprinomectin vs ivermectin
where can i purchase viagra over the counter how much is viagra in usa
best online pharmacy tech programs online pharmacy
tadalafil 5 mg goodrx iron dragon liquid tadalafil
female viagra pill buy sildenafil cost 100mg
brand levitra online pharmacy levitra pill size
tri luma online pharmacy pharmacy rx world
10 mg levitra levitra now online
quit smoking best drugstore shampoo
reputable canadian pharmacies online viagra pharmacy
canada online pharmacy community rx pharmacy warren mi
cipa canadian pharmacies canadian pharmacies ratings
discount drugs from canada buying prescription drugs in mexico online
canadian pharmacy online canada okay google canadian pharmacies on the web
buy modafinil 100mg for sale
do canadian pharmacies require prescriptions chinese online pharmacy
buy provigil sale buy modafinil 100mg online cheap
is erythromycin a penicillin api erythromycin
purchase modafinil online cheap buy provigil 200mg pill
buy modafinil 200mg pill
buy provigil buy generic modafinil buy provigil 200mg sale
buy provigil 200mg pill modafinil 100mg drug
buy modafinil online
order provigil for sale order provigil without prescription order modafinil 100mg pill
generic modafinil
erythromycin opthalmic ointment erythromycin eye ointment dosage
https://erythromycin1m.com/# erythromycin ophthalmic ointment for cats
how Long Do Cialis Side Effects Last?
erythromycin for gastroparesis
buy generic provigil 200mg provigil 100mg pill
provigil pills provigil 200mg uk provigil online order
what Herbs Do The Same Thing As Cialis?
erythromycin base uses for erythromycin
how Long Does Cialis Take To Start Working?
https://erythromycin1m.com/# erythromycin overdose
Cialis When Generic In Us?
order modafinil 200mg online oral modafinil 200mg
uses for erythromycin erythromycin iv
https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.site/ canadian online drugstore
buy prescription drugs without doctor comfortis for dogs without vet prescription
canadian drug prescription drugs
erythromycin vs tetracycline https://erythromycin1m.com/#
canadian drug prescription drugs online without doctor
hydroxychloroquine generic names
canada pharmacy hydroxychloroquine generic hydroxychloroquine 200mg generic hydroxychloroquine otc
price of viagra buy viagra online canada
stromectol for sale price of stromectol absolute accuracy
viagra cost viagra cost per pill
Pingback: 3christie
where can i buy viagra over the counter viagra shop
https://stromectolusdt.com/ stromectol pills
buy real viagra online 100mg viagra
https://hydroxychloroquinex.com/ hydroxychloroquine for sale from canada
buy stromectol 12mg
order amoxicillin online uk buy amoxicillin 500mg
buy ivermectin in canada buy ivermectin 12 mg
amoxicillin 250 mg amoxicillin generic
https://clomidforsale.life/# clomid online no prescription
plaquenil hydroxychloroquine hydroxychloroquine online otc
lipitor 40 mg tablet price lipitor generic canada
lasix 40mg lasix tablet
https://buynolvadex.store/# nolvadex price
https://erectionpills.best/# best ed treatment
buy ivermectin pills ivermectin tablets
https://diflucan.icu/# diflucan for sale
where to buy diflucan pills how to get diflucan otc
https://gabapentin.icu/# neurontin 100 mg tablets
lucky777plus
ceaser slot
slotomania slot machines free games
ivermectin 3mg price
where can i get diflucan over the counter diflucan 100
https://withoutprescription.store/# online canadian pharmacy
medicine neurontin capsules buy generic neurontin
https://diflucan.icu/# diflucan 150 tab
https://withoutprescription.store/# prescription drugs online without doctor
https://erectionpills.best/# male erection pills
diflucan capsule 50 mg over the counter diflucan pill
https://gabapentin.icu/# neurontin for sale online
cheap pet meds without vet prescription ed meds online canada
https://gabapentin.icu/# neurontin price south africa
https://doxycyclineonline.store/# buy doxycycline
doxycycline cheap doxycycline
drugs online google viagra dosage recommendations
https://stromectol.life/# stromectol 12 mg tablets
https://clomidonline.icu/# clomid 100mg for sale
stromectol 3mg tablets stromectol 12 mg tablets
https://edpills.best/# pills for ed
medications for ed ed meds online
https://stromectol.life/# stromectol for sale
stromectol 12 mg tablets stromectol usa
best pharmacy online canadian drug prices
free vpn unlimited
windscribe vpn reviews
kodi vpn
https://medrxfast.com/# buy prescription drugs online
buy prescription drugs online legally carprofen without vet prescription
online casino usa
united states online casino
online real money casinos
https://medrxfast.com/# discount prescription drugs
casino usa online
sign up bonus no deposit casino
casino no deposit bonus
[url=https://medrxfast.com/#]canada ed drugs[/url] best non prescription ed pills