Experts question credibility of environmental claims made by UK restaurant chain
Last modified on Fri 20 Aug 2021 13.00 BST
The environmental credentials of Leon’s “carbon-neutral” burgers have been questioned after it emerged the fast-food chain was using controversial carbon offsets to make the claim.
In January, Leon announced it would become the first restaurant chain in the UK to serve carbon-neutral burgers and fries at more than 60 locations by reducing and offsetting the emissions they produce.
Alongside excluding high-carbon meats such as beef from its menu and using more sustainable energy sources, the company pledged to neutralise emissions by purchasing carbon credits from three rainforest conservation and tree-planting schemes.
But scientists and carbon market specialists have raised concerns about Leon’s claim and some of the credits they have used to substantiate their advertising.
One rainforest conservation project, the Peruvian Amazon, run by a partnership between two logging companies and a conservation NGO, was featured in a joint Guardian and Unearthed investigation that uncovered serious concerns about the project’s credibility.
The investigation found that the Redd+ (reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation) carbon credits, which are generated by preventing hypothetical deforestation, were unlikely to represent real emission reductions and threats to the forest had been overstated.
The findings at the time were fiercely criticised by Verra, a US non-profit that administers the world’s leading carbon credit standard, VCS (Verified Carbon Standard).
Britaldo Soares-Filho, a deforestation modelling expert and professor at the Institute of Geosciences at the Federal University of Minas Gerais in Brazil, whose software was used to model the hypothetical deforestation the project selected by Leon was preventing, warned they were “phantom credits” with little benefit to the climate.
“Beware of what you are eating: carbon neutrality of burgers sauced with Redd+ credits will not digest well,” he said.
Leon strongly disputed the claim it was using “phantom credits” and said it was confident the credits accredited by Verra helped “prevent greenhouse gas emissions, protect vital biodiversity and create sustainable livelihoods for forest communities”.
The company said it was aware of the Guardian’s investigation into the Madre de Dios project but was confident that the credits were helping to protect threatened rainforest.
Freya Chay, an analyst at CarbonPlan, a US organisation that scrutinises the credibility of climate solutions, said that while she sympathised with Leon, the company could not make a rigorous claim using the credits due to outstanding concerns about the project and the VCS standard, routinely used by other companies to make environmental claims.
“One common characteristic of Leon’s claim that stands out is how heavily it relies on the purported trustworthiness of third-party standards to establish offsets’ validity. Project credibility is based almost entirely on the third-party VCS seal of approval. This pattern is common and raises questions about who should be on the hook when offset credits turn out to be bad,” Chay said. “There’s no accountability, even when the problems are clear.”
“In this case, reporting has indicated significant concerns about the Madre de Dios project and the VCS standard under which it was credited, and VCS has apparently since changed its methodology to address a methodological shortcoming present in the Madre de Dios project. But as is the norm in these situations, the VCS methodological changes are forward-looking and don’t affect credits issued under existing projects.”
An increasing number of companies are using carbon credits to make environmental claims about their business practices, including airlines offering passengers the chance to “fly carbon neutral”, either by purchasing credits or doing so on their behalf.
James Dyke, the assistant director at the Global Systems Institute at the University of Exeter, said a burger could not be carbon neutral by virtue of purchasing offsets.
“First, offsetting schemes will not reduce atmospheric carbon now. Planting trees to take carbon out of the atmosphere will require years if not decades. Second, there are no assurances that carbon will stay locked up in a tree. Someone may come along and cut it down, or it could be burnt down during a wildfire,” he said.
“Third, some offsetting schemes are really promises to not be as destructive as we otherwise could be. So they are really about payments to protect existing forests from destruction. That doesn’t remove any carbon, it just tries to stop more of it entering the atmosphere.”
In a statement, Leon said sustainability was at the heart of its business and it had committed to be net zero by 2030. Carbon offsetting was just one part of its strategy to tackle unavoidable emissions, the company said, and the Madre de Dios project was one of many it supported.
Leon added: “Of the 13 burgers we’ve had on our menu this year, six have been vegan, giving our customers a wide range of naturally lower-carbon products to choose from.”
It also said the Madre de Dios project was one of many it backed.
A representative of the Madre de Dios project told the Guardian they disputed the findings of the previous investigation and were confident that their project was doing important work to prevent deforestation.
tadalafil cost walmart tadalafil side effects
cheap cialis pills for sale buy tadalis
tadalafil tadalafil dosage
cost of cialis buy tadalis
tadalafil online with out prescription where to order tadalafil tablets
tadalafil price walmart tadalafil daily online
prescription tadalafil online buy generic cialis online with mastercard
tadalafil cialis where to order tadalafil tablets
tadalafil side effects tadalafil cost in canada
cheap cialis pills for sale cialis tadalafil
tadalafil liquid canada generic tadalafil
tadalafil without a doctor prescription cialis at canadian pharmacy
buy cialis side effects of tadalafil
prescription tadalafil online cheap generic cialis for sale
cialis without prescription cialis cost
https://cialismat.com/ cost of cialis
https://cialisedot.com/ cheapest tadalafil cost
buy generic cialis online with mastercard buy tadalis
tadalafil tadalafil liquid
cialis cost cheap cialis pills for sale
tadalafil online with out prescription https://cialisedot.com/
canada generic tadalafil buy tadalafil
prescription tadalafil online what is tadalafil
where to order tadalafil tablets tadalafil order online no prescription
buy cialis pills https://nextadalafil.com/
tadalafil liquid tadalafil side effects
generic cialis tadalafil https://cialismat.com/
where to order tadalafil tablets tadalafil drug
https://cialiswbtc.com/ cialis without prescription
cheap generic cialis for sale lowest price cialis
generic cialis tadalafil https://cialisusdc.com/
generic cialis tadalafil generic cialis online fast shipping
generic cialis tadalafil side effects for tadalafil
tadalafil without a doctor prescription generic cialis online fast shipping
buy tadalis where to buy cialis without prescription
where to buy tadalafil on line tadalafil brands
generic cialis tadalafil https://extratadalafill.com/
where to buy cialis without prescription where to buy tadalafil on line
https://cialisicp.com/ tadalafil
cheap cialis pills for sale side effects for tadalafil
tadalafil blood pressure tadalafil goodrx
tadalafil/sildenafil combo c-tadalafil. 40mg yellow/mango
cost of cialis https://extratadalafill.com/
cialis vs sildenafil when to take sildenafil
stromectol medication stromectol online pharmacy
tadalafil 10mg dosage what are the side effects of tadalafil
ivermectin 1 topical cream ivermectin over the counter
tadalafil without a doctor prescription tadalafil goodrx
nitrates and sildenafil how much sildenafil can i take
tadalafil mechanism of action in bph tadalafil ingredients
tadalafil https://cialisusdc.com/
https://cialisbusd.com/ cheap generic cialis for sale
ivermectin 6 stromectol 6 mg tablet
tadalafil 100mg best price tadalafil 5mg online
generic cialis tadalafil buy cialis
ivermectin 3 mg buy stromectol uk
stromectol 3 mg tablets price ivermectin medication
ivermectin india cost of ivermectin medicine
ivermectin 0.5 lotion stromectol tablets for humans for sale
ivermectin cost canada ivermectin 3mg for lice
buy ivermectin cream for humans ivermectin tablets
ivermectin price canada ivermectin 3 mg tablet dosage
cost of ivermectin 3mg tablets ivermectin 3mg tab
ivermectin 400 mg brands stromectol order
ivermectin 4 tablets price ivermectin tablets
ivermectin for humans ivermectin generic name
buy viagra canada order viagra online
sildenafil citrate tablets ip 100mg sildenafil otc usa
Malegra DXT plus canadianpharmacymeds
viagra soft 100mg sildenafil 100mg uk cheapest
erectile dysfunction medications pharmacy programs online
generic levitra online pharmacy levitra 60 mg
how to take cialis 20mg best prices cialis
cheap prescription drugs canada quick rx pharmacy
ivermectin pill half life of ivermectin
tadalafil plus 21mg liquid tadalafil citrate
cialis dosage recommended best canadian pharmacy for cialis
online mail order pharmacy ed drugs from canada
what to expect after taking ivermectin for scabies ivermectin for humans
sildenafil 50 mg mexico viagra pharmacy
cialis 10mg cialis manufacturer coupon 2018
pictures of penis on cialis generic cialis, no prescription, paypal
viagra uk otc viagra pill for women
taking levitra levitra duration
levitra coupon free trial levitra 100mg
canadian pharmacy st petersburg fl on line pharmacy
northwest pharmacy, canada the canadian pharmacy complaints
listing of prescription drugs pharmacy checker
how reliable are canadian pharmacies pharmacy online stores
canadian pharmacy cipa mail order prescription drugs
best online thai pharmacy texas state board of pharmacy
modafinil 200mg cheap generic modafinil 100mg
modafinil 100mg ca
generic provigil 200mg buy provigil 200mg sale
provigil 100mg usa
erythromycin ophthalmic ointment usp erythromycin overdose
order provigil 200mg online cheap
buy modafinil 200mg without prescription brand provigil
order modafinil 200mg online order provigil 100mg without prescription purchase provigil online cheap
provigil 100mg us
provigil 100mg price
provigil 100mg pill provigil sale
erythromycin pregnancy https://erythromycinn.com/#
modafinil without prescription modafinil 200mg pill order modafinil 200mg online cheap
how To Use Cialis For Best Results?
erythromycin and clindamycin http://erythromycinn.com/#
provigil sale buy provigil 100mg sale
provigil canada
erythromycin opthalmic
what Does Cialis Do For Men?
how Long Does Cialis Take To Be Effective?
erythromycin cream for acne
how Long After Taking Isosorbide Mn Er Can You Take Cialis?
http://erythromycin1m.com/# erythromycin overdose
provigil uk provigil 200mg cheap
erythromycin ophthalmic ointment for newborns
how Often To Take 10mg Cialis?
what Is Better Levitra Viagra Or Cialis?
https://erythromycin1m.com/# erythromycin generic name
when Does The Patent On Cialis Expire?
what is generic for plaquenil plaquenil 200mg bid
stromectol 12mg for sale stromectol canada buy 6 mg ivermectin
buy stromectol 3 mg tablets http://stromectolusdt.com/
how to get off plaquenil hydroxychloroquine 200mg for arthritis pain hydroxychloroquine where to buy online
express pharmacy
Pingback: 2consequence
stromectol otc ivermectin without a doctor prescription
https://www.ivermectinoge.com/ ivermectin for covid
how to get hydroxychloroquine tablets buy plaquenil canada
ivermectin tablets for humans ivermectin canada
hydroxychloroquine 200 mg price buy hydroxychloroquine
buy stromectol usa ivermectin 6 mg