Analysis: For 20 years Home Office has gone to extreme lengths to return Afghans to country they risked their lives to flee
Last modified on Wed 18 Aug 2021 05.13 BST
Announcing that Britain is looking at a “bespoke arrangement” for Afghan refugees, the foreign secretary, Dominic Raab, declared on Tuesday that Britain was a “big-hearted nation” which had “always been a country that has provided safe haven for those fleeing persecution”.
This is not a picture of Britain’s asylum system that many Afghan asylum seekers in the UK will recognise. Over the past 20 years, the Home Office has gone to extreme lengths to return thousands of them back to the country they risked their lives to flee.
British officials have faced repeated criticism from international refugee organisations for the frequency with which young Afghan asylum seekers have been denied formal refugee status when they turn 18, despite having spent large parts of their childhood in the UK; many of these adolescents have subsequently been forcibly returned to the country they left years earlier.
Until Tuesday morning, the official Home Office position, set out on its website, was that Kabul was a safe place to which refused asylum seekers should be returned. A spokesperson said Home Office-organised enforced returns to Afghanistan have this week been “paused” while officials “consider the situation”.
“We have been closely monitoring the situation in Afghanistan and due to the escalations this weekend are urgently updating our information and policies to inform asylum claims,” the spokesperson said.
Several immigration experts said the scene of extreme panic at Kabul airport on Monday was a very stark illustration of the degree of fear experienced by clients who have fled Taliban-controlled areas of Afghanistan over the past 20 years.
Jamie Bell, an immigration lawyer with the law firm Duncan Lewis, who has represented about 100 Afghan citizens claiming asylum, said those seeking refuge here had for years faced a “lengthy uphill battle to be recognised as refugees”.
Until 2016, the Home Office was operating monthly charter flights to return refused asylum seekers to Afghanistan en masse; more recently the UK government has continued to return people whose refugee claims have been rejected to Kabul on commercial flights.
“For years, Afghans have fled their home country seeking refuge in the UK only to be disbelieved, detained and forcibly returned to the warzone that they left behind. My hope now is that the culture of disbelief and disinterest towards Afghan asylum seekers becomes a thing of the past and the thousands seeking protection in the UK already are given the support and protection that they deserve,” Bell said.
Although there is a determination to welcome any scheme designed to offer asylum to people whose lives have been upended by the situation in Afghanistan, lawyers, charity workers and immigration experts stress that a new policy for Afghan asylum seekers will need to be combined with a radical rethinking of proposed new immigration legislation.
There is particular concern about aspects of the nationality and borders bill, which is designed to penalise refugees who have been forced (in the absence of safe, legal alternatives) to make their way into this country through irregular routes – most recently on boats across the Channel.
Beth Gardiner-Smith, of Safe Passage, a charity helping unaccompanied child refugees access legal rights, said: “The government cannot in all conscience talk about a compassionate response, while continuing to push through immigration legislation that punishes those refugees, many of them from Afghanistan, who come into this country through irregular routes. The reality is, even with an expanded resettlement programme, most Afghan refugees will still not have access to the official programmes.”
The Syrian vulnerable person’s resettlement scheme set out to resettle 20,000 Syrians in need of protection by 2020, was administered by the UNHCR, and has been broadly viewed positively by immigration experts. There has been speculation that a new scheme could be similar in scale, but with the UNHCR warning that there could be up to 3 million internally displaced people in Afghanistan, a figure that has increased by up to 500,000 since the beginning of this year, pressure for places on any scheme will be intense.
Any new government scheme to resettle Afghan refugees would need to commit to firm targets for the number of people to be helped, to avoid the risk of dwindling political willingness to fulfil commitments, once the crisis has passed. Campaigners remember how a government promise to support 3,000 unaccompanied refugee children in Calais 2016, many of them from Afghanistan, ended up only helping about 380.
Several charities stressed that there needed to be wholesale cultural change within the Home Office departments assessing Afghan asylum claims, pointing to a historical absence of compassion, which has led to so many young Afghan asylum seekers – who studied for their GCSEs in British schools – being removed from the country when they become adults.
Between 2009 and 2015, the Home Office deported 605 Afghans who arrived in the UK as unaccompanied minors. The approach toward Afghan asylum seekers was particularly tough; in the same period, only 6% of unaccompanied Afghan children were given refugee status, compared with 15% of other child asylum seekers.
Bella Sankey, the director of Detention Action, which has assisted large numbers of Afghan asylum seekers held in immigration removal centres over the past two decades, said: “The UK government has forcibly removed thousands of Afghan asylum seekers to danger over the past 20 years. It must now urgently step up, bring these people back and create a generous resettlement scheme for those most at risk from Taliban brutality.”
cialis without a prescription https://cialismat.com/
https://cialisvet.com/ cheapest tadalafil cost
generic tadalafil from uk tadalafil generic
tadalafil side effects generic tadalafil from uk
tadalafil blood pressure https://cialismat.com/
tadalafil order online no prescription tadalafil order online no prescription
tadalafil brands what is tadalafil
tadalafil order online no prescription where to buy cialis without prescription
tadalafil generic where to buy what is tadalafil
cialis at canadian pharmacy cialis without a prescription
cost tadalafil generic cialis without a prescription
lowest price cialis tadalafil brands
what is tadalafil https://cialisicp.com/
tadalafil online generic cialis tadalafil
generic tadalafil from uk buy cialis
tadalafil goodrx cialis cost
cheapest tadalafil cost buy generic cialis online with mastercard
tadalafil generic where to buy buy generic cialis online with mastercard
tadalafil generic where to buy buy tadalafil
prescription tadalafil online what is tadalafil
tadalafil price walmart https://cialisusdc.com/
https://cialismat.com/ tadalafil order online no prescription
https://cialisvet.com/ tadalafil cialis
buy tadalafil https://extratadalafill.com/
tadalafil drug tadalafil
best price usa tadalafil what is tadalafil
canadian pharmacy tadalafil 5mg
cheap cialis pills for sale tadalafil drug
generic tadalafil from uk generic tadalafil from uk
cialis|buy cialis|generic cialis|cialis pills|buy cialis online|cialis for sale
tadalafil online with out prescription https://cialisedot.com/
viagra for sale cheap
how much is viagra
where to buy cheap viagra in usa
usa over the counter sildenafil
buy cheap viagra online australia
tadalafil online tadalafil goodrx
cialis tablets 20mg for sale
https://cialismat.com/ prescription tadalafil online
cheap tadalafil 20mg
blum minipress
lipitor 40
buy cialis cheap cialis pills for sale
how to cialis
cialis cost canada generic tadalafil
generic clopidogrel 75 mg
generic tadalafil from uk tadalafil cost walmart
cialis 2.5 mg daily use
ivermectin lice
tadalafil cialis https://cialisedot.com/
sildenafil 30 mg sildenafil 20 mg review
what is the drug sildenafil used for is sildenafil available over the counter
tadalafil cost walmart cost tadalafil generic
ivermectin 400 mg brands cost of ivermectin cream
female viagra pill buy viagra generic wholesale
tadalafil best price india
purchase tadalafil online tadalafil generic online
ivermectin for covid
is sildenafil 20 mg the same as viagra? sildenafil citrate canadian pharmacy
feldene capsule
cialis prescription online canada
ivermectin uk coronavirus stromectol generic
cialis india cheap
cost of cialis tadalafil drug
ivermectin 0.1 ivermectin 4000
ivermectin 12 ivermectin buy nz
ivermectin 1mg ivermectin 6 mg tablets
ivermectin stromectol 3 mg tablet
ivermectin 3mg dose stromectol uk buy
stromectol online ivermectin gel
ivermectin 50 mg ivermectin 3mg tab
stromectol 3mg stromectol ebay
ivermectin 400 mg ivermectin cost australia
generic cialis online tadalafil generic
liquid tadalafil purchase peptides tadalafil
buy generic viagra online cheap viagra 100mg
generic pharmacy online net va online pharmacy
victoza canada pharmacy Tadalis SX
cialis paypall canadian cialis
walmart pharmacy online account pharmacy online 365
buying online pharmacy check canadian pharmacies website
levitra cost at target levitra for sale canada
buy viagra without a prescription buy generic viagra india
ivermectin where to purchase ivermectin for rabbits
ivermectin covid 19 uptodate ivermectin, metronidazole
best online viagra canada how to get sildenafil prescription
cialis side effects with alcohol buying cialis in south africa
can i buy prescription drugs from canada texas online pharmacy
levitra time how much does levitra cost at walmart
over the counter drug that works like cialis cialis generic timeline 2018
pharmacy rx world.com online pharmacy canada reviews
viagra 400mg viagra 100 price in india
buy generic levitra online price comparison levitra viagra cialis
canada cialis for sale cialis dose
fry pharmacy lambert and la canada accredited pharmacy technician schools online
singapore pharmacy online store viagra online us pharmacy
canadian pharmacy canadian tx overseas pharmacies
vipps canadian online pharmacy legitimate online pharmacies
Accupril cheapest pharmacy prescription drugs
pharmacy drugstore online discount viagra canadian pharmacy
canadian pharmacy chains canadian pharmacies for cialis
order modafinil online modafinil 100mg over the counter
Cardizem ER canadian pharmacy saxenda
purchase modafinil sale cheap modafinil 100mg
cialis 20mg canadian pharmacy phentermine canada pharmacy
provigil brand buy modafinil 200mg for sale
modafinil oral
buy generic provigil provigil ca
modafinil buy online provigil sale
online pharmacy tech online pharmacy review
buy modafinil 200mg online cheap purchase modafinil pill
provigil 200mg without prescription
order provigil pill buy provigil 100mg pills
modafinil 200mg brand order modafinil 200mg pill modafinil over the counter
erythromycin ophthalmic ointment http://erythromycin1m.com/#
order provigil 200mg provigil usa
provigil 100mg generic order generic modafinil buy modafinil 100mg
cheap modafinil modafinil 100mg over the counter order modafinil without prescription
buy provigil 100mg without prescription