“They were careless people.” Thus did F. Scott Fitzgerald memorably describe Tom and Daisy Buchanan in “The Great Gatsby.” “They smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money or their vast carelessness,” letting others “clean up the mess they had made.”
Nearly a half-century ago, after smashing up things and creatures in South Vietnam, the United States engaged in a comparable retreat. It does so again today in Afghanistan.
President Joe Biden promises that “there’s going to be no circumstance for you to see people being lifted off the roof” of the US embassy in Kabul. Maybe not. But the similarities between the debacle that culminated atop the US embassy in Saigon in 1975 and the one unfolding before our very eyes demand thoughtful attention.
Advertisement
In life, walking away from the mess you’ve made makes a recurrence more likely. Acknowledging the mess makes learning at least a possibility. Americans learned next to nothing from Vietnam. Might we do better this time?
Recall that a mere five years after the fall of Saigon, Americans elected a president who declared that the Vietnam War had been a “noble cause.” For the United States and for the South Vietnamese, the American war in Vietnam had actually been an unmitigated catastrophe. Ronald Reagan gave his fellow citizens permission to pretend otherwise. And so, shielded by our money and indulging in our own vast carelessness, we did.
Apart from a somber memorial on the National Mall in Washington, the substantive legacy of Vietnam reduced to two items, one temporary and one enduring. For a brief interval after the fall of Saigon, the United States hesitated to intervene abroad. This was the so-called Vietnam Syndrome. With more lasting effect, Vietnam prompted Americans to abandon their traditional reliance on citizen-soldiers in favor of an all-volunteer force of dutiful professionals.
Advertisement
Once the Cold War ended, with elites developing a pronounced appetite for putting American military might to work, the Vietnam Syndrome became an impediment. The all-volunteer force provided a readily available means for satisfying that appetite.
As a consequence, once Ronald Reagan left office, military supremacy and military activism became signatures of American statecraft. Panama, Kuwait, Somalia, Haiti, Bosnia, Kosovo, plus the sundry nations targeted for US airstrikes: Even before 9/11, the list of places that the United States invaded or attacked was becoming a long one. Once the United States embarked upon its misguided global war on terror, the list became longer still.
Consigned to the role of spectators rather than participants, ordinary citizens happily played along. Or at the least, few found any reason to object. To the extent that the Vietnam-era antiwar movement survived, it did so on life support.
Yet the overall results of US military activism — Iraq offering an especially vivid example — have been anything but pretty. Let me suggest that the outcome of the Afghanistan War — the longest in our nation’s history — now renders a definitive judgment on a costly pattern of reckless behavior.
The time to clean up has arrived. A place to begin is by acknowledging three essential lessons that should shape basic US policy going forward. The outcome of the Afghanistan War brings each of those lessons into clear focus.
First, waging global war as a response to terrorism is a fool’s errand. Failure in Afghanistan should bring down the curtain on an enterprise that began 20 years ago next month.
Advertisement
Second, coercive nation-building undertaken by foreign armies exacts enormous costs and rarely yields success. This is especially the case in a place like Afghanistan about which even today Americans remain stolidly ignorant.
Third, and most importantly, it’s past time to recognize that the most pressing threats to our security and well-being are not “out there” in places like Central Asia but “back here” where Americans live. Those threats, including climate change, environmental degradation, insecure borders, and disease, not to mention domestic unrest, pose a far more immediate danger to the American people than anything the Taliban are capable of doing.
That the Biden administration has grotesquely mismanaged the US military disengagement from Afghanistan is unquestionably the case. But the issue demanding concerted attention is not how we left, but why we went there in the first place, what we did, and why we stayed so long. To ignore those questions is to invite a further bout of the vast carelessness to which Americans are prone.
Andrew Bacevich is president of the Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft. His new book is “After the Apocalypse: America’s Role in a World Transformed.”
follow us
Digital Access
Home Delivery
Gift Subscriptions
Log In
Manage My Account
Customer Service
Help & FAQs
Globe Newsroom
Advertise
Newsletters
View the ePaper
Order Back Issues
News in Education
Search the Archives
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
Terms of Purchase
Work at Boston Globe Media
tadalafil side effects https://cialismat.com/
tadalafil goodrx https://cialisedot.com/
lowest price cialis https://cialisusdc.com/
cialis without prescription side effects for tadalafil
cialis at canadian pharmacy tadalafil blood pressure
tadalafil online with out prescription https://cialistrxy.com/
tadalafil without a doctor prescription tadalafil liquid
tadalafil brands tadalafil price walmart
side effects of tadalafil tadalafil side effects
side effects of tadalafil https://cialisusdc.com/
tadalafil price walmart where to buy generic cialis online safely
tadalafil without a doctor prescription side effects of tadalafil
buy cialis https://cialismat.com/
cost of cialis cost tadalafil generic
cialis cost where to buy tadalafil on line
generic cialis online fast shipping tadalafil order online no prescription
lowest price cialis https://cialisicp.com/
cialis at canadian pharmacy https://cialistrxy.com/
cheapest tadalafil cost tadalafil drug
where to buy cialis without prescription canada generic tadalafil
buy tadalis tadalafil dosage
cialis tadalafil what is tadalafil
lowest price cialis cialis tadalafil
cheap cialis pills for sale cost of cialis
tadalafil generic where to buy prescription tadalafil online
where to buy generic cialis online safely cost tadalafil generic
https://cialistrxy.com/ prescription tadalafil online
buy cialis tadalafil online with out prescription
best price usa tadalafil cost of cialis
buy generic cialis online with mastercard tadalafil
tadalafil brands tadalafil without a doctor prescription
where to buy cialis without prescription https://extratadalafill.com/
tadalafil generic where to buy cost tadalafil generic
prescription tadalafil online https://cialisedot.com/
where to get tadalafil generic tadalafil from uk
tadalafil goodrx best price usa tadalafil
tadalafil brands side effects of tadalafil
tadalafil blood pressure tadalafil price walmart
best place to buy sildenafil citrate online sildenafil contraindications
sublingual viagra buy cheap viagra
como tomar sildenafil edegra sildenafil 100 mg
stromectol 3mg tablets stromectol ivermectin 3 mg
viagra 400mg viagra online canadian pharmacy
buy cialis pills cialis without a prescription
tadalafil costco what is tadalafil oral jelly
60 mg sildenafil sildenafil prescribing information
stromectol 6 mg tablet ivermectin drug
cialis cost tadalafil without a doctor prescription
prescription tadalafil online where to get tadalafil
ivermectin 9 mg ivermectin australia
buy stromectol online ivermectin 0.08
ivermectin 400 mg brands ivermectin 6mg dosage
ivermectin cream uk stromectol oral
ivermectin 12 mg ivermectin 3 mg tabs
cost of stromectol medication ivermectin 1%
ivermectin pills ivermectin cream uk
stromectol 3 mg price stromectol 3mg
ivermectin lotion price ivermectin 5ml
stromectol buy stromectol pill price
generic viagra cheap natural alternatives to viagra
viagra cialis or levitra cheapest tadalafil
stromectol medication topical ivermectin cost
sildenafil diabetes sildenafil 100mg tablet
combitic global caplet pvt ltd tadalafil tadalafil solubility tissue culture
viagra in canada viagra
canada pharmacy prices weight loss drugs approved in canada
cialis tadalafil 5mg lilly best tadalafil
cialis israel cialis canadian pharmacy no prescription
cheapest pharmacy for prescription drugs pharmacy technician certification
live pharmacy ce online care rx pharmacy tallahassee fl
levitra when to take levitra lowest price
canadian pharmacy cheap sildenafil generic viagra where to buy
ivermectin 12mg ivermectin for dogs mange
viagra 50mg uk order viagra 100mg online
ivermectin scabies treatment ivermectin plus
cialis manufacturer cialis bleck
internet pharmacy mexico online pharmacy without prescriptions
tadalafil 100mg best price elitenet tadalafil
levitra user reviews levitra cialis combination
15 rx pharmacy oxycodone online pharmacy
cialis med dapoxetine canadian pharmacy cialis 20mg
sildenafil pharmacy uk viagra online cheap india
levitra alcohol levitra trial offer
cialis payment with paypal cialis indien bezahlung mit paypal
diplomat pharmacy allmed rx specialty pharmacy
cheapest canadian pharmacy for viagra canadian online pharmacy
Norpace buy pain pills online pharmacy
tretinoin cream canadian pharmacy maple leaf pharmacy in canada
mail order pharmacy reputable online canadian pharmacy
pharmacy intern drug store king canadian pharmacy discount code
Imitrex lyrica canada pharmacy
mobile rx pharmacy skin care
canadian pharmacy king reviews online pharmacy delivery delhi
buy modafinil sale purchase provigil without prescription buy modafinil for sale
buy modafinil pill order modafinil
buy provigil online cheap provigil us order modafinil without prescription