Subscribe or Login
Subscribe or Login
Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login
When the Blyvooruitzicht Gold Mine in Carletonville was abruptly liquidated eight years ago, everything changed for Pule Molefe. Overnight, operations stopped, thousands of people lost their jobs and environmental mitigation and management measures ground to a halt.
Molefe, who was working in Blyvooruitzicht’s procurement department, remembers it as a dark, bleak time.
“It was really bad. Basically, you woke up in the morning and you were told that there’s no employment for you anymore. You never planned for that and you have a family to feed.”
To survive, some people turned to small-scale, illegal mining.
“People were desperate,” Molefe says. “Everything fell apart. It was a mining community so everything was controlled by the mine: our electricity was paid by the mine, our water services and our refuse removal. Now, there was nothing.”
Over the years, the number of people living in the mine village has swollen by thousands. “We were about 3000 before, now it’s easily four times that. The mine was strict about who could live in the village. Now, there’s no control of housing. People have filled the garages and Blyvoor’s office space.”
Molefe says there is a “grey area” in cases like Blyvoor. “If you go to the government for help, they say it’s private property. If you go to the mines, they say they are no longer responsible. So the community is left on their own. Then, with the liquidators, there’s so little they can do and so much they cannot do,” he says.
“I don’t think this is the right way of closing a mine because it affects so many people.”
Mariette Liefferink, chief executive of the nonprofit Federation for a Sustainable Environment, says the plight of mining-affected residents in Springs, Krugersdorp and Klerksdorp is similar to the experience of the residents of the Blyvoor village when the Grootvlei Mine in Springs, Mintails’ operations in Krugersdorp and Shiva Uranium Mine (a Gupta-owned mine) were liquidated or placed under business rescue.
“These cases represent disastrous mine closures,” she says.
Now the department of mineral resources and energy has unveiled a new mine closure strategy, which is envisioned to deal with the detrimental fallouts of mine closures. According to the strategy, mine closure must be environmentally and socially sound and economically viable. Typically the closure of mines results in often irreversible environmental degradation and social and economic hardship in surrounding mining-affected areas.
The draft strategy envisions transforming land damaged by mining into agricultural projects, tourism enterprises and the self-generation of energy by mining companies. Non-mining use of mining lands for economic programmes must be planned as an integral element of a mine’s life cycle.
The draft reads: “Given the current crisis on energy supply, self-generation of energy by mining companies is a critically important aspect of a post-mining economy. The recent development where operating mines generate their own power will create a generation base that can be used to provide energy to post-mining development.” This, too, can provide sustainable energy where long-term water pumping and water treatment are required.
But Liefferink points out that crop production, including household food gardens and grazing for livestock are high-risk land uses because of the potential harm caused by the bioaccumulation of metals, including uranium, in the soil.
In its submitted comments on the draft, Tarisai Mungunyani, a lawyer at the Centre for Environmental Rights, says that in any mine closure strategy, it is people and the environment that bear the greatest risk and such strategies should address the harmful effects as a priority.
She says that closure strategies should prioritise land uses that support livelihoods and access to land and land reform as a political and economic imperative.
“Inequality in our country is sharply aggravated by the resettlement of communities to make way for mining, perpetuating centuries of dispossession.”
According to the strategy, the closure of a mine will often affect the remaining mines in that region. The unintended consequence of this could negatively affect the safe operation of neighbouring mines and potentially result in the cessation of their operations.
“The key problem area is surface water contamination, suspected groundwater contamination on a regional scale,” says the draft.
Substantial damage includes the socioeconomic effects of mine closure, air pollution by windblown dust, radioactivity, land degradation and land instability caused by undermining and seismicity and damage to biodiversity, according to the draft.
Another of the objectives is to manage water at mining sites, including a post-closure mine water strategy for the area. This will prevent the externalisation of the pumping and treatment costs of mine water to neighbouring mines, the “last man standing” or to the state.
The document details how temporary closure, or care and maintenance, can be “cynically used” as a loophole for avoiding expensive closure programmes. “The endemic invasion of derelict and abandoned mines by illegal miners has become a major social, safety, economic and legal problem for the country.”
Estimates of “zama zama” outputs of gold production exceed R14-billion a year, making South Africa one of the largest sources of illegal gold in Africa, the draft says, noting how this activity is also rife in the platinum group metal sector and around the “plethora” of abandoned mines. The facilitation and control of legal secondary mining of waste deposits by small-scale and artisanal miners is another key aspect of mine closure, according to the draft.
Liefferink says significant concerns remain about the enforcement of the policy, given the track record of implementation of the previous mine closure strategies. She says the draft strategy needs to have teeth.
“We can compare this strategy to a Rolls-Royce, but unfortunately we only have the capacity for a Volkswagen,” Liefferink says.
Her organisation highlights how the most common practice for mining companies to avoid their closure commitment is the “pass the parcel” approach — when mines are sold close to closure to poorer-resourced companies, which relieves them of the responsibility and liability of dealing with the problems of closure. “And at the end you sit with a little scavenger company that only scavenges the last bit of resources” and doesn’t rehabilitate the environment or ensure the closure is socially and economically viable.
Stephinah Mudau, the head of environment at the Minerals Council, says in principle it welcomes and supports the draft strategy. “[It] provides a strong basis to strengthen regional collaboration between mines and various stakeholders in ensuring environmental sustainability, and socioeconomic succession during and post mine closure. The Minerals Council recommends that extensive engagements be held with the mining company experts and specialists.”
Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.
Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them.
If you haven’t already, you can subscribe to the Mail & Guardian for less than the cost of a cup of coffee a week, and get more great reads.
Already a subscriber? Sign in here
function loadDoc() {var xhttp = new XMLHttpRequest(); xhttp.onreadystatechange = function() { if (this.readyState == 4 && this.status == 200) { document.getElementById(“pressoffice”).innerHTML = this.responseText; }}; xhttp.open(“GET”, “https://mg.co.za/scripts/rss/pressofficeServer.php?menu=false&items=5&feed=http://pressoffice.mg.co.za/feed/rss2.php”, true); xhttp.send();} loadDoc();
For all the latest information and advice from the Department of Health relating to Covid-19, please visit sacoronavirus.co.za
Contact Us
Story Tip-offs
Legal
Ethics & Social Media Policy
About Us
Corrections And Clarifications
Advertising
Subscriptions
Mail & Guardian Jobs
Find property for sale
We value your feedback
Subscriber login FAQ
All material © Mail & Guardian Online. Material may not be published or reproduced in any form without prior written permission.
cialis tadalafil tadalafil generic where to buy
https://cialisusdc.com/ buy tadalis
where to buy generic cialis online safely tadalafil online
tadalafil side effects cheap generic cialis for sale
tadalafil goodrx generic cialis online fast shipping
https://extratadalafill.com/ cheapest tadalafil cost
canada generic tadalafil tadalafil online with out prescription
side effects of tadalafil https://cialiswbtc.com/
tadalafil dosage tadalafil generic where to buy
buy tadalafil tadalafil brands
cialis tadalafil cost of cialis
where to order tadalafil tablets cialis cost
cialis cost cost tadalafil generic
cheapest tadalafil cost generic cialis online fast shipping
buy cialis buy tadalis
cialis at canadian pharmacy tadalafil online with out prescription
generic cialis tadalafil tadalafil
tadalafil cialis generic cialis online fast shipping
canada generic tadalafil cost tadalafil generic
tadalafil drug tadalafil cialis
tadalafil price walmart cost of cialis
side effects for tadalafil buy cialis pills
cialis at canadian pharmacy https://cialisvet.com/
generic cialis tadalafil tadalafil blood pressure
cost tadalafil generic cost tadalafil generic
cialis at canadian pharmacy where to buy tadalafil on line
tadalafil blood pressure tadalafil price walmart
where to buy cialis without prescription side effects for tadalafil
tadalafil order online no prescription tadalafil daily online
tadalafil drug buy tadalis
tadalafil order online no prescription https://nextadalafil.com/
buy cialis pills https://cialiswbtc.com/
where to order tadalafil tablets cialis cost
tadalafil drops is tadalafil a controlled substance
order tadalafil lilly tadalafil 20 mg
buy tadalafil what is tadalafil
online generic viagra price viagra
online prescription tadalafil best tadalafil
ivermectin 12 mg ivermectin 24 mg
sildenafil 50mg price sildenafil shelf life
texas meds tadalafil blue sky tadalafil reviews
price of ivermectin liquid ivermectin 1%
tadalafil goodrx https://cialisvet.com/
tadalafil 5mg generic cialis tadalafil vs viagra
ivermectin 400 mg ivermectin 3mg dosage
cheap generic cialis for sale tadalafil cost walmart
stromectol tab 3mg stromectol where to buy
ivermectin 50 mg ivermectin pills
ivermectin pills human ivermectin pills
buy stromectol pills buy ivermectin pills
ivermectin cream uk stromectol price in india
purchase stromectol ivermectin 20 mg
stromectol cream ivermectin generic name
ivermectin 400 mg buy liquid ivermectin
purchase viagra natural viagra alternatives
tadalafil effects tadalafil liquid review
cialis reviews cheapest cialis
tadalafil usa non prescription tadalafil
costco pharmacy online refill best canadian mail order pharmacies
online viagra cheap buying viagra in canada safely
cialis tadalafil buy online how much does tadalafil cost
viagra price sildenafil 1000 mg
big online pharmacy bernie sanders canada drugs
levitra side effects medications levitra or viagra
overnight pharmacy cialis dapoxetine and generic cialis
arrow pharmacy my brand rx va online pharmacy
generic tadalafil india zhengzhou debao tadalafil
buying cialis cialis drug interactions
canada pharmacy canada cialis canadian pharmacy
ivermectin for head lice ivermectin wormer for horses
where to buy generic viagra in canada how to get viagra online in usa
does 20mg cialis work cialis max dose
generic cialis 200 mg cialis canadian pharmacy ezzz
generic viagra 100mg price best price for genuine viagra
levitra sex pills levitra without prescription
levitra free trial sample purchase levitra online
northwest pharmacy canada reviews northwest canadian pharmacy reviews
reputable online canadian pharmacy canada discount drugs online
buying prescription drugs from canada vyvanse online pharmacy
why do drugs cost less in canada best canadian prescription prices
pharmacy tech Casodex
which canadian pharmacy is legitimate online pharmacy walmart
us pharmacy online good online mexican pharmacy
order modafinil 100mg online
oral provigil order provigil 100mg modafinil 200mg price
canadian pharmacy sildenafil citrate canadian pharmacy overnight delivery
buy modafinil 200mg for sale order provigil 200mg without prescription
provigil order online buy modafinil 200mg
provigil 100mg over the counter modafinil 100mg canada
modafinil 100mg brand
cheap provigil 100mg
erythromycin abbreviation erythromycin ointment for newborns
order modafinil 100mg for sale modafinil 200mg oral
order modafinil generic order generic modafinil
erythromycin base mechanism of action of erythromycin
how Fast Is Cialis?
what Happen When A Girl Take Cialis?