A Fight for Sacred Land in the American West
This compelling work of visual nonfiction describes the controversy over the potential building of a copper mine on a piece of federally owned land, Oak Flat, that is sacred to the San Carlos Apache people. Lauren Redniss traces the stories of the San Carlos Apache, the Nosie family who belong to that tribe, the nearby Arizona mining town of Superior, the Gorham family of miners who live there, and the history of conflicts over land use between the US government and Indigenous peoples. She supplements her prose with her own beautifully hand-drawn illustrations. Oak Flat plays with space, illustration, and style to challenge what it means to be a book, just as, for many Christians, studying Indigenous cultures challenges our definition of religion.
The most compelling part of the book is the story of the Sunrise Dance, the coming-of-age ceremony for Apache girls, which takes place on Oak Flat. The Sunrise Dance is a “four-day ritual central to Apache community and culture during which a girl who has recently begun menstruating reenacts the Apache creation myth.” Redniss introduces the Sunrise Dance early on and later spends an entire chapter walking through every step of the dance with the women of the Nosie family.
During the dance, the girl “needs to endure the heat, the fatigue, and the hunger without complaint.” The girl transforms into the White Painted Woman from the creation story, gaining “heightened powers.” By attending to the story of the Sunrise Dance, Redniss effectively adds another layer to an already intersectional conflict. Taking Oak Flat away from the Apache is not just an attack on the environment or on Indigenous peoples. Robbing them of their dance is specifically an attack on Indigenous women and girls, proving that environmental, Indigenous, and feminist issues are inherently intersectional.
Although Oak Flat focuses on the Apache, Redniss respectfully complicates the story by examining other sides. Paralleling her interviews with the Nosies, she interviews the Gorhams, who make their living as miners in the nearby town of Superior. In this way, she humanizes the mining towns. Mining, “by definition, an enterprise with diminishing returns,” turns towns into “tiny enclaves full of abandoned buildings and ‘For Rent’ signs.” It leaves poverty and environmental damage in its wake—not to mention the physical dangers to the miners. Redniss doesn’t try to force her readers to empathize with the Gorhams; she lets them draw their own conclusions by presenting an accurate picture of the vulnerability that exists on both sides. It’s clear that both the Apache and miners like the Gorhams are at the mercy of the mining industry.
Redniss reveals that the environmental issues at Oak Flat are similarly complicated. Even after describing all of the environmental degradation that the mine could cause, she notes that “clean technologies generally require more copper than traditional technologies. . . . Mitigating planetary warming will almost certainly cause a further surge in demand for copper.” This detail—and the fact that it’s likely to catch many readers off guard—exemplifies how the environmental movement typically excludes Indigenous voices. The problems caused by the climate crisis are inherently intersectional; thus, the solution needs to be intersectional as well. Clean energy at the expense of Indigenous peoples is not a viable solution.
Oak Flat also touches on the relationship between Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples—particularly with respect to Christianity. “Coerced conversions to Christianity became commonplace” throughout Apache history, as assimilation policies made Apache religion illegal and boarding schools took Apache children from their families. The Catholic Church had its own conflict with the Apache over another sacred space, Mount Graham, in the 1980s. Today, there are Mormon, Pentecostal, Baptist, and Roman Catholic churches on the San Carlos reservations, according to Redniss. How are those parishes involved in the struggle for Oak Flat? These details may prompt Christians to examine their role in the suffering of the Apache.
Oak Flat’s illustrations, which form their own story, complement the multiple threads Redniss weaves through the book. For example, early in the book, she writes, “The contested copper under Oak Flat was created by stars that were born and died billions of years ago. The copper is older than Earth itself. A mine here would operate for about 40 years.” The only words on the page, these three sentences appear on a black background alongside a large, colorful drawing of an exploding star. Through the temporal contrast between billions and 40 and the spatial contrast between words and images, Redniss plays with space and time to contextualize the Oak Flat controversy. The point isn’t that the mine controversy is small and petty compared to the universe; it’s that the mine is important because it is part of an infinite cosmos.
Oak Flat is not just about a conflict over a mine in Arizona, this page tells readers. It’s about a conflict within the order of the universe. The facing page is also black, with stars speckling the background. The five short sentences here are broken up and spaced in such a way that the prose takes on the visual appearance of a poem. Similarly, the book ends with solid black pages that have minimal text in the form of a poem, creating the effect that the story of Oak Flat is bookended by expansiveness.
Redniss also challenges style norms in the way she uses interviews. Instead of integrating quotations into her own prose, often she simply states the speaker’s name, followed by a colon and the quote itself. This formatting choice lets the interviewees speak for themselves, which is especially important for Indigenous voices.
Redniss challenges traditional book formats in a fashion that is particularly effective for her subject matter. Both the book’s content and its form make Oak Flat a stimulating and poignant read.
or
where to get tadalafil https://extratadalafill.com/
generic cialis online fast shipping cheap generic cialis for sale
cialis at canadian pharmacy buy cialis pills
canada generic tadalafil where to order tadalafil tablets
tadalafil cialis lowest price cialis
tadalafil cost in canada where to order tadalafil tablets
tadalafil order online no prescription buy tadalafil
tadalafil cost in canada https://cialistrxy.com/
tadalafil without a doctor prescription cialis without a prescription
side effects of tadalafil buy cialis
https://extratadalafill.com/ prescription tadalafil online
Very energetic blog, I loved that bit. Will there be a part 2?
Also visit my blog – jam hoki main slot
tadalafil side effects tadalafil
canada generic tadalafil cheap generic cialis for sale
cialis without prescription cialis cost
tadalafil online with out prescription cialis cost
https://cialisusdc.com/ tadalafil liquid
side effects for tadalafil prescription tadalafil online
where to get tadalafil lowest price cialis
https://cialistrxy.com/ tadalafil goodrx
tadalafil order online no prescription https://cialisbusd.com/
tadalafil side effects cialis without a prescription
cialis without prescription cialis at canadian pharmacy
tadalafil without a doctor prescription cialis tadalafil
cost of cialis generic tadalafil from uk
cialis without a prescription buy tadalafil
buy tadalis cheapest tadalafil cost
generic cialis tadalafil https://extratadalafill.com/
cheapest tadalafil cost buy tadalafil
where to buy generic cialis online safely tadalafil
tadalafil cialis where to buy generic cialis online safely
buy tadalis https://cialisvet.com/
tadalafil goodrx where to get tadalafil
tadalafil brands tadalafil without a doctor prescription
cost of cialis generic cialis online fast shipping
tadalafil cialis without prescription
over the counter viagra free viagra
buy tadalafil 20mg online cialis tablets tadalafil
ivermectin stromectol cheap stromectol
bluesky tadalafil generic tadalafil tablets
sildenafil doesn’t work how long does sildenafil work
side effects of tadalafil generic cialis tadalafil
tadalafil liquid for sale best prices for tadalafil 20mg
can i buy viagra online in uk pharmacy viagra generic
side effects of tadalafil what is tadalafil
what is tadalafil tadalafil price walmart
ivermectin brand name ivermectin eye drops
https://cialiswbtc.com/ tadalafil goodrx
ivermectin 50 ivermectin 4 mg
ivermectin where to buy ivermectin purchase
ivermectin 0.5% lotion stromectol pill for humans
cost of ivermectin lotion ivermectin uk buy
ivermectin 4000 mcg where to buy stromectol online
stromectol australia stromectol 3 mg tablets price
ivermectin 6mg ivermectin 200
ivermectin generic cream ivermectin humans
ivermectin 8000 mcg buy ivermectin nz
stromectol tablets for humans for sale stromectol tablets
ivermectin iv stromectol tablets buy online
tadalafil tablets 5mg cialis maximum dose
ivermectin cream cost stromectol tab price
maxim peptide tadalafil snafi tadalafil
sildenafil generic viagra sildenafil effects on female
what is the use of tadalafil tablets best research tadalafil 2017
best sildenafil brand generic sildenafil over the counter australia
health canada controlled drugs and substances buy prescription drugs online cheap
levitra dosage dose is cialis better than levitra
walmart store locator pharmacy pharmacies with canadian drugs in lakeland fl
Duricef Nimotop
cialis patent expiration 2016 cialis buy info/
viagra brand name in india sildenafil 100mg without prescription
cialis vi cialis efectos secundarios
canadian council for accreditation of pharmacy programs universities in canada pharmacy
buy viagra discount sildenafil 100mg from india
ivermectin dose for covid does ivermectin kill lyme disease
ivermectin 3mg tab ivermectin for sale canada
peptide liquid tadalafil tadalafil overnight delivery
viagra 400 mg sildenafil 50mg prices
buy cheap levitra buy levitra without prescription
cipa certified canadian pharmacy why are drugs cheaper in canada
levitra directions non prescription levitra
cialis not working first time buy cialis online paypal
navarro pharmacy store locator www canadian pharmacies
pharmacy rx one rx plus pharmacy sanford
rx pharmacy services canadian pharmacy hcg
best canadian pharmacy to order from vipps certified online pharmacy list
pharmacy tech online classes banfield online pharmacy
canadian animal pharmacy pharmacy app store
meds rx pharmacy prescription drugs canada
modafinil without prescription
buy provigil 100mg generic
is reliable rx pharmacy legit med store pharmacy fort worth
buy provigil 100mg online cheap order provigil 100mg
vipps certified canadian pharmacy medstore online pharmacy
order modafinil 200mg for sale
erythromycin oint erythromycin ophthalmic ointment usp
provigil 100mg drug cheap provigil 100mg
modafinil online buy buy modafinil 200mg online provigil 100mg tablet
modafinil 200mg cost modafinil 200mg tablet
azithromycin and erythromycin erythromycin ointment
what Works Better Than Viagra And Cialis?
uses for erythromycin erythromycin ophthalmic ointment usp 0.5
when Generic Cialis Available?
https://erythromycinn.com/# erythromycin ophthalmic eye drops
erythromycin abbreviation erythromycin ophthalmic ointment
order modafinil online provigil 100mg oral buy provigil 200mg without prescription
how Long Does Cialis Take To Work?
erythromycin vs azithromycin erythromycin for dogs
what Is Better Cialis Or Viagra?
erythromycin ophthalmic ointment for cats http://erythromycinn.com/#
stromectol 0.5 mg ivermectin online canada cheapest stromectol online
buy 12mg stromectol https://ivermectinuni.com/
plaquenil online
stromectol 12 mg tablets
Pingback: 1johannes
plaquenil without a doctor prescription buy 200 mg hydroxychloroquine
stromectol 12 mg tablets stromectol tablets
plaquenil hydroxychloroquine 200mg tablets cost of generic plaquenil hydroxychloroquine online canada
stromectol 30mg
buy ivermectin 6 mg https://www.ivermectinusd.com/
ivermectin canada buy 12 mg ivermectin