Throughout the summer, area concerts have featured the 251-year-old Beethoven, as well as works by composers who specially admired the master. In addition, the concerts have introduced the music of significant rising composers, especially women and people of color, to make god on a promise to bring gifted artists of the current generation. At the Koussevitzky Shed on Sunday, July 25th, Beethoven was represented by his third piano concerto, performed by Yefim Bronfman; his admirers by Robert Schumann, (both as a composer and aa a distinguished critic), with his D-minor symphony; and musical youth in the person of the Iranian-Canadian Iman Habibi, who penned a short Beethoven tribute, Jeder Baum spricht (“Every tree speaks”), for the birthday year.
Iman Habib took his title from Beethoven’s sketchbook, one that the master carried while walking in the natural beauty of the Vienna Woods or the city parks. While sketching the Pastoral Symphony, he studied the trees around him and felt something ineffable in them. In planning his piece, Habib moved this thoughtful pondering two centuries forward, thinking about Beethoven’s possible response to today’s environmental degradation. Composed for an orchestra with the same instrumentation as Beethoven’s Fifth, Jeder Baum spricht suggest the sonorities of Beethoven’s best-know work, but it does not at any point make obvious borrowings. Rather it suggests an action of pursuing goals and finding them blocked and resisted, requiring an approach from a different direction. It reaches climaxes with intense orchestral energy and drive, ending—as some of Beethoven’s most-loved works do with a sunny ray of hope that, however much it might have been inspired by Beethoven, makes its point in its own way, without specific aping or quoting.
In Beethoven’s Piano Concerto No. 3, in C Minor, Yefim Bronfman richly characterized the moods and ideas of the three quite different movements: the vigorous, almost military sound of the opening, with its firm scale passage followed by a dotted rhythm suggesting timpani (though Beethoven craftily withholds the timpani at first); the quite, almost prayerful second movement, with rich fioriture played rapidly and delicately throughout; and the sudden move to cheeky, rollicking themes in the finale. With each of these different kinds of music, Bronfman’s approach was fully alive and fitting to the various moods. The hushed, mysterious end of the first movement, following the cadenza (a passage that Beethoven learned from Mozart’s C-minor concerto at the same place) turned the assertive drum figure into a hushed mystery, with the timpani actually appearing at last to take over the dotted rhythm theme (apparently one of Beethoven’s first ideas for the piece). This allowed the surprisingly bright E-major opening of the slow movement, where Bronfman’s limpid songfulness highlighted the uniqueness of its expression. And, after having all but disappeared into that tranquil music, he returned as a kind of comic figure moving through the playful elements of the final rondo.
Schumann attempted symphonies, essentially on the Beethoven model, after his years o composing truly original music for the piano. After his marriage to Clara Wieck, he began, partly at her urging, to move to larger forms including the orchestra. The Symphony No. 4 was actually the second he composed, though Schumann reworked it considerably almost a decade later, after he had completed his other three symphonies. In this reworking, he emphasized thematic interactions among all the different movements, extending an approach found (in different degrees) especially in Beethoven’s Fifth and Ninth symphonies, which he admired greatly. Completed the early 1850s, Schumann’s Fourth was the last German symphony to enter the general repertory for almost a quarter century, until Brahms finally brought forth his first.
Beethoven certainly inspired Schumann’s thematic ideas, but (as has often been noted) his problematic treatment of the orchestra often left it to conductors to balance the sonorities and clarify the effect. Some conductors have gone so far as to reorchestrate by cutting lines that they deemed overly duplicative. (Schumann was a conductor of uncertainly abilities mostly working with players that he didn’t quite trust, so he often overloaded the parts to ensure that someone would come in). Of course with the Boston Symphony under Nelsons, such concerns are otiose. The conductor can and did adjust balances to clarify the colors, and bring out the various related themes, building a firm and satisfying traversal.
Steven Ledbetter is a freelance writer and lecturer on music. He got his BA from Pomona College and PhD from NYU in Musicology. He taught at Dartmouth College in the 1970s, then became program annotator at the Boston Symphony Orchestra from 1979 to 1997.
No Comments »
RSS feed for comments on this post.
© B. M. Int.
If you would like to contribute articles or reviews to the Intelligencer, please familiarize yourself with our submission guidelines. Subscribe to the Intelligencer.
cheap generic cialis for sale tadalafil daily online
cialis cost cost of cialis
cialis without a prescription side effects for tadalafil
https://cialisvet.com/ tadalafil online with out prescription
tadalafil order online no prescription tadalafil cialis
https://cialisvet.com/ tadalafil brands
https://cialismat.com/ tadalafil side effects
tadalafil drug cheapest tadalafil cost
tadalafil generic where to buy cheapest tadalafil cost
tadalafil goodrx tadalafil generic where to buy
cialis without prescription lowest price cialis
cost of cialis lowest price cialis
buy tadalis https://cialistrxy.com/
tadalafil brands where to get tadalafil
tadalafil goodrx tadalafil without a doctor prescription
cheap cialis 100mg
ivermectin drug
viagra cream price
buy disulfiram without prescription
tadalafil cost in canada where to order tadalafil tablets
https://cialisicp.com/ where to buy tadalafil on line
tadalafil cost walmart https://cialistrxy.com/
viagra pills
cialis|buy cialis|generic cialis|cialis pills|buy cialis online|cialis for sale
buy generic viagra online europe
cialis tablets canada
cialis for women
female viagra buy online
viagra 200mg uk
cialis 100mg uk
https://nextadalafil.com/ where to buy tadalafil on line
tadalafil blood pressure cost of cialis
lowest price cialis cialis cost
buy cialis pills
buy generic ciprofloxacin
sildenafil discount price
cheap cialis pills for sale generic cialis online fast shipping
tadalafil price walmart cialis at canadian pharmacy
tadalafil goodrx tadalafil online
atenolol drug
viagra on line viagra india
sildenafil citrate 50mg sildenafil (viagra)
buy oral ivermectin ivermectin 10 ml
cost tadalafil generic tadalafil cialis
robaxin price uk
sildenafil what is it used for sildenafil premature ejaculation
tadalafil and dapoxetine tadalafil buy
tadalafil research liquid tadalafil 20 mg uses
cialis brand online
ivermectin 3 mg tablet dosage ivermectin drug
tadalafil best price usa tadalafil
https://extratadalafill.com/ tadalafil generic
australia viagra price
ivermectin price usa ivermectin 9mg
ivermectin 18mg ivermectin tablets order
stromectol tablets for humans buy stromectol canada
ivermectin 1 cream generic order stromectol online
ivermectin lotion price ivermectin where to buy
ivermectin brand stromectol ireland
ivermectin 50mg/ml stromectol over the counter
ivermectin 3 mg ivermectin australia
ivermectin drug ivermectin lotion 0.5
ivermectin humans stromectol ivermectin tablets
stromectol buy buy ivermectin canada
ivermectin 0.5% ivermectin 1%cream
viagra on line buy viagra new york
ivermectin lotion cost stromectol ivermectin 3 mg
superman combo viagra cialis cialis definition
buy sildenafil 50mg how long does sildenafil
cheap viagra online side effects of viagra
tadalafil 20mg lowest price tadalafil tablets erectafil 20
does tadalafil expire 40 mg tadalafil
buy medication without an rx cvs pharmacy little canada mn
levitra 20 mg cena levitra brand name
optum rx pharmacy help desk the cns depressants include various prescription drugs referred to as
cialis drug cialis genetic
canadian pharmacy ltd. inhouse pharmacy
buy viagra no prescription online viagra pharmacy india
canadian colleges of clinical pharmacy texas state board of pharmacy
stromectol prioderm ivermectin and heart disease
cialis online without perscription cialis blog
ivermectin cream nih approved ivermectin
cheap viagra canadian pharmacy cost of viagra in us
farmacia genericos comprar cialis generico online tadalafil precio tadalafil cheap
levitra 5mg dose compare viagra cialis and levitra
how to take cialis 20mg cialis price south africa
buy viagra free shipping cheap discount viagra
levitra trial offer levitra sample packs
reputable online pharmacy list of approved canadian pharmacies
cialis uses cialis doesnt work
prescription drugs become illegal when __________. prices pharmacy
canada pharma limited llc eu online pharmacy
canadian prescription drugstore domperidone from canadian pharmacy
prescription drugs defined pharmacy delivery
rx us meds pharmacy Cabgolin
how to get prescription drugs without a doctor canadian viagra
canadadrugpharmacy online pharmacy without insurance
provigil 100mg uk provigil 200mg oral
cheap modafinil 200mg provigil 200mg over the counter
buy provigil 100mg online buy provigil 100mg for sale
canadian pharmacy 365 cvs pharmacy app store
erythromycin overdose what is erythromycin ophthalmic ointment used for
provigil uk cheap provigil cheap modafinil
order provigil pills provigil drug buy provigil for sale
24 hour pharmacy pharmacy conversion course canada
buy provigil 200mg online cheap buy modafinil 100mg pill
provigil 200mg canada modafinil tablet
modafinil brand provigil 200mg price
erythromycin benzoyl peroxide topical gel erythromycin opthalmic ointment
order modafinil 200mg modafinil 100mg ca
how Long Does Cialis Take To Treat Bph?